creepy | The Mary Sue

Subscribe Login

Latest creepy Stories

70yo South Carolina Man Compliments a Woman’s Wedding Ring at Walmart. Then He Says Something Unsettling and Walks Away: ‘I Still Have All My Fingers’

By Kopal Jun 19th
LA Woman Contacts a Tattoo Artist for a Leg Sleeve, but Then He Gives Her ‘creepy’ Vibes, Making Her Change Her Mind: ‘You’re Intuition Is Strong!!!’

By Sanchari Ghosh May 29th
‘Not a single review mentioned it’: Airbnb hosts asks why guests gave low rating. Then they reveal the creepy hair wall

By Rebekah Harding Aug 30th
10 Creepy Furby Stories That Make Us Fear the Return of the Furby

By Rachel Ulatowski Jul 30th
Guy Creates Pokédex for “Catching” Women, Shares It With Fraternity

By Briana Lawrence Jul 1st
Welsh Treasure Trove Reminds Us of the Memento Mori

By Jessica Mason Apr 15th
This Great British Bake Off Trailer Is a Very Bad Bake

By Vivian Kane Aug 3rd
Dear Annabelle: Creation Marketing Team: Please Stop Ruining My Life

By Vivian Kane Aug 2nd
Things We Saw Today: Samurai Jack Fan Tribute Shows Us What We Could Have Had

By Jessica Lachenal Jul 5th
Commercial Featuring Creepy Baby Spider-Man is Selling What?

By Susana Polo Apr 11th
Video Of Beached Jellyfish-Thing Reminds Us That The Ocean Is Filled With Terrifying Horrors

By Sam Maggs Dec 29th
This Mouth is an Eye, Your Argument is Invalid [Unsettling Makeup Effects]

By Susana Polo Feb 26th
Women’s Thighs Are Becoming Japan’s Newest Billboards

By Ian Chant Feb 21st
Student Paints Creepy Illusions In Her Spare Time, Inspires Us To Find Cooler Ways to Procrastinate

By Kellie Foxx-Gonzalez Jun 25th
Overly Attached Girlfriend is Back With Parody of Carly Rae Jepsen’s “Call Me Maybe”

By James Plafke Jun 18th
Hilariously Creepy Girl Enters Justin Bieber’s Girlfriend Contest, is Awesome

By James Plafke Jun 7th
Abandoned by Facebook and Foursquare; Creepy, Stalker-Enabling App Girls Around Me is Pulled by Developer

By Susana Polo Apr 1st
Vintage Valentines Are Weirdly Violent, Disturbing

By Max Eddy Feb 14th
Dark Knight Style Joker Baby Doll May Be Totally Serious

By Jill Pantozzi Dec 27th
Unofficial Ad for Sour Patch Kids is Terrifying, Oddly Effective

By Max Eddy Dec 6th