Skip to main content

Woman says she gave up her paid window seat for an older passenger and was close to tears by the end of the flight: ‘being nice did not pay off’

She says the woman seated beside her hit her “at least 25 times” during the flight.

A passenger says the older woman who took her window seat spent the flight elbowing, singing and leaning on her. Pauline Rowbelle described the experience in a Threads post. According to Upworthy, she always sits in a window seat, but an older woman traveling with her mother was already in hers when she reached her row.

A third passenger, who she says was also in the wrong seat, offered her the middle seat. She “politely declined” and agreed to give up the window, taking the aisle seat since it would be easier to get out of. She states she was being patient and stayed quiet because the woman was older.

She claims the woman seated in the middle hit her “at least 25 times” and tried to put an empty cup into hers while she was still drinking. According to her, the woman gestured while speaking with her daughter, and her arms moved into the passenger’s space. The woman kept going without saying anything, she writes, until she finally stopped and the passenger took a breath.

She says the contact continued throughout the flight.

She says the woman then sang for a full 15 minutes, even though she had noise-canceling headphones on. She also says the woman headed for the bathroom without alerting her and was “literally on top of me.” Back in the row, the woman leaned on her while her daughter helped with a seatbelt, she says. She told herself it was fine because 30 minutes were left on the 7 a.m. flight. She adds that staying silent had been “eating me up inside.”

She says, “I’m ready to cry because I’m so overstimulated.” With eight minutes left, the woman leaned on her again and rested an elbow on her thigh while stretching. She closes the thread with advice for other passengers. “If you paid for a seat that you prefer, don’t give it up,” she writes, adding that “being nice did not pay off.”

She also asks passengers to confirm their seat assignments before sitting down. She says she is not telling anyone to stop being kind, but that some situations call for being “a little bit more selfish for your own mental health and comfort.” She shared a photo of her seat and wrote “1/3 of my seat is literally her clothes.” All details are based on her Threads post.

Seat disputes of this kind are not unusual. One man refused to give up his window seat for an injured passenger, and another passenger says the woman beside her cried for three hours after she refused to switch seats. According to SmarterTravel, a passenger with a valid ticket and seat assignment is not required to move. Senior editor Caroline Morse Teel states, “You aren’t obligated to give up your seat or make any accommodations for this passenger.”

The one exception is a flight attendant’s instruction to move, in which case she advises passengers to “comply and complain to the airline later.”

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Anshu Thakur is a writer who covers culture and trending stories across the internet. Her work focuses on the intersection of internet trends, entertainment, and fan reactions.