Florida man is arrested after police say he mailed a peanut butter-covered card to his ex-wife’s best friend, who has a life-threatening allergy
I would never open a greasy envelope with my bare hands again.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. is facing charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence in Florida. Police say he mailed a greeting card covered in peanut butter to his ex-wife’s best friend, a dangerous move as the woman has a life-threatening peanut allergy. Plantation police arrested the 68-year-old at his home on Friday, according to Law & Crime.
The woman reportedly found a greasy blue envelope after returning home from work in August 2025, and the card inside was smeared with a brown substance she recognized as peanut butter. As she is deathly allergic, she dropped it and rushed to wash her hands. She still suffered hives on both arms and tingling that lasted about six hours.
Investigators believe Cancellare knew about the allergy and intended to cause death or serious bodily injury by exposing her to a known allergen. The pair had known each other for more than 20 years, and police wrote that he would absolutely know, as she would alert restaurant staff about her allergy during countless dinners with the two couples.
Police say a post office kiosk photo led them to Cancellare
Police tracked the source of the peanut butter card by looking at the stamps. The two Forever stamps used on the envelope were purchased at a Davie Post Office kiosk about a week before the victim received it. Police say a Visa card belonging to Cancellare paid for them, and the kiosk captured the buyer’s face in a photo.
Police allege he tried to cover his tracks by driving to a post office in another city, wearing sunglasses inside, and using a fictitious name and return address. However, when investigators showed the photo to the victim, she immediately recognized him. Several acquaintances, including a former bandmate, also identified him.
Cancellare was married to the victim’s best friend, and police describe the divorce as contentious. He reportedly blamed the victim for the breakup, and investigators say he made remarks to friends about wanting to harm people connected to it. The two last saw each other about three years earlier, when she observed the property split in the divorce settlement.
Investigators stated that the victim can experience a reaction through touch, ingestion, or even through the air. They noted that without immediate intervention, she could die. The experience reportedly caused her extreme distress that was still visible when she provided a statement over a year later.
Researchers have tested whether simply smelling peanut butter can set off a reaction
Peanut allergy is the leading cause of food allergy deaths in the U.S. The most common trigger is eating peanuts, though breathing in dust or aerosols such as peanut flour may also cause a reaction, according to Mayo Clinic guidance. Even a tiny amount can cause a severe reaction in some people.
In a 2003 study of 30 peanut-allergic children, covered dishes of peanut butter held to their noses for 10 minutes caused no reactions, per the University of Nebraska Medical Center. Researchers concluded the smell alone is unlikely to trigger an allergic reaction. However, the victim’s reported hives came after she handled the card itself.
Cancellare has reportedly posted bond and could face up to 15 years in prison if convicted of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon, a second-degree felony in Florida.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]