Real estate brothers bragged about hunting women in secret group chats: ‘We’re not predators, we were just playboys’
“We are running out of prey.”

The Alexander brothers, once celebrated as luxury real estate icons, are now facing the reality of 30-year prison terms following their conviction for federal sex trafficking. According to Fox News, Tal, Oren, and Alon Alexander, who previously moved through elite social circles in New York, Miami, and the Hamptons, were found guilty on March 9, 2026. A federal jury in New York City determined that the trio operated a long-term scheme involving the drugging and sexual assault of numerous women.
The scale of their conduct was significant, with prosecutors alleging that the brothers targeted at least 70 victims over two decades. The internal culture of the group was exposed through secret messages presented during their six-week trial. These communications, which are highlighted in the new Peacock docuseries titled The Wolves of Real Estate: The Alexander Brothers, revealed the language the brothers used to describe their targets.
In one instance, Oren wrote, “We are running out of prey,” while another message from the brothers warned that the “boys are hungry.” The brothers appeared to view their interactions with women as a game, with Oren allegedly claiming he would hunt women in the same way he would hunt a high-value real estate client.
The documentary highlights the language the brothers used
Director Emma Schwartz, who helmed the docuseries, noted that the brothers attempted to frame their behavior as harmless during the trial. “The brothers at trial, they said, ‘We’re not predators, we were just playboys,’” Schwartz said. She explained that the documentary serves as a counter to this narrative by providing their own words as evidence.
Schwartz added that the group chats often utilized terminology that treated women as commodities. This included discussions about getting the best return on investment when funding trips for their targets.
The brothers, who rose to prominence as star brokers at Douglas Elliman and later co-founded the firm Official, built their lifestyle on a foundation of wealth and high-profile transactions. They were involved in a notable $240 million penthouse sale in 2019, which set a record for residential real estate in the United States.
However, prosecutors argued that this status was used to facilitate their crimes. They allegedly lured women with promises of luxury travel and exclusive access, only to isolate and assault them once they arrived at various properties.
Testimony from 11 women painted a grim picture of these encounters
One victim, Lexi Zettle, described Tal as “a prince in my eyes” before he began pressuring her to engage in sexual acts with his business associates. She stated, “They treated me like a rag doll, like I was this disposable thing.” Another woman, who testified about being raped in a shower, described the experience as an eternity of terror.
When the sentencing occurred on October 27, U.S. District Judge Valerie E. Caproni delivered a harsh rebuke to the trio. She told them, “Your conduct was monstrous,” and compared their dual lives to the story of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.
The legal fallout has extended beyond the courtroom. While the criminal trial concluded with the 30-year sentences, the brothers also faced scrutiny for their efforts to influence public opinion during the proceedings. According to a Fox News report from November 8, allegations emerged that the brothers paid independent journalists to write favorable coverage of their case. Two writers, Daniel Mael and Frank Parlato, were named in connection to these claims.
Both journalists have denied that they were paid to write biased content
Mael confirmed in a statement on X that he accepted funds from the brothers’ publicist, Juda Engelmayer, to help subsidize his reporting costs, but he insisted that no one exercised editorial influence over his work. Mael stated, “No one requested favorable coverage, no one dictated a single word, and no one exercised the slightest editorial influence over my reporting.”
Engelmayer defended the move, claiming that the mainstream coverage of the case was overwhelmingly negative and that he wanted to ensure the defense’s perspective was heard. Parlato also maintained that his reporting remained independent, stating that he wrote based on his own beliefs and court records.
Despite the guilty verdicts and the lengthy prison sentences, the brothers continue to deny the core allegations. During their final statements before sentencing, they expressed regret for their past behavior but insisted they never broke the law. Tal described the situation as an atomic bomb destroying his life, while Oren argued that they were merely products of the hookup culture of their time.
The brothers have stated they plan to appeal their convictions. Meanwhile, three victims have moved forward with civil litigation against the trio.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]