Skip to main content

DoorDasher waits in a downpour with a remade order she thought was stolen. Then the customer walks up holding the original

Is that smart or insensitive on the customer’s part?

A DoorDash driver says a customer used her to get a free meal. She convinced restaurant staff to remake an order she believed had been stolen before it reached the customer, then waited in heavy rain outside his apartment for a PIN-verified handoff, only to watch him walk up already holding the original bag.

Content creator Mae (@maedyourday) shared the story in a TikTok video, recounting a shift she worked the summer before her freshman year of college. She said she accepted a well-paying DoorDash order from Jersey Mike’s, but when she got to the counter, staff told her it had already been picked up.

The order still showed as active in her driver app, so Mae persuaded employees to make a replacement and drove through a downpour to deliver it. She said she only realized afterward that the customer himself had taken the original meal.

A free remake and a rainy wait turned into a gut punch

Mae said she was about 30 deliveries into her DoorDash side hustle when this order came in. Before asking for a remake, she checked her app and asked a fellow driver for advice.

While she waited, Mae said she messaged the customer to apologize for the delay and explain that someone had taken his original order, and he told her to take her time. Once the restaurant remade it, she drove to his apartment complex in pouring rain.

Mae said she stepped into a deep puddle and stood without any cover because the delivery required a direct handoff and a confirmation PIN. When the customer didn’t answer the door, she called him, and he told her he was just leaving the gym and asked her to wait.

“This guy comes strolling up to his apartment like five minutes later after I’m getting torrentially downpoured on, and I see him walk up with the Jersey Mike’s bag in his hand,” Mae recalled. “I hand him his bag, he gives me the PIN, he goes inside. Now he has two Jersey Mike’s bags in his hand.”

Mae said she believes the customer placed the order, picked it up himself, and then waited for a driver to get a free remake, leaving him with two meals for the price of one. “I’ve never felt so scammed in my life,” she said. The customer’s side of the story couldn’t be verified.

Open pickup shelves make it easy for orders to walk off

Many restaurants use open, customer-accessible shelves for completed orders to cut down on crowding and speed up handoffs. In a QSR Magazine piece, an executive at a smart-locker company wrote that these shelves are vulnerable to theft and to orders being picked up by the wrong person, which leads to remakes and longer waits.

DoorDash itself recommends that restaurant staff check the order ID and customer name on a driver’s phone before handing over food. In August 2024, the company also announced that some customers, particularly those who frequently report delivery problems, would have to give drivers a four-digit PIN to confirm they received their orders.

That PIN check happens at the final handoff, not at the restaurant’s pickup counter. It can help confirm an order reached the right person, but it doesn’t stop someone from taking an unattended order before the assigned driver arrives.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Kopal primarily covers politics for The Mary Sue. Off the clock, she switches to DND mode and escapes to the mountains.