Skip to main content

California man claims Costco refused to compensate him $1,700 after mechanics found water in the fuel tank of his family car

California man claims Costco refused to compensate him $1,700 after mechanics found water in the fuel tank of his family car

Ryan Clark (@ry.clark), from California, told social media that his family car refused to start after refueling at Costco. After taking it to a mechanic, Clark said they found water and sediment in his fuel tank.

He explained that in October, his wife took their two children to Costco. Clark said his family doesn’t get gas at Costco because it’s farther from their house. However, because there were no lines at the pump and the car needed fuel, his wife allegedly decided to fill up.

“She fills up $180 worth of gas; she gets a receipt—that’s the important part. She drives home, and about a mile away from home, or half a mile away from home, her check engine light comes home, and her car starts to shake,” Clark alleged. Nevertheless, he said his wife still made it home to their driveway despite the issue.

He did not provide a screenshot of the receipt in his TikTok video. Leading up to the incident, Clark claimed that the car had no issues. Clark also said he checked the car but couldn’t figure out why it wasn’t starting.

Clark said they eventually had their car towed to the dealership. Although he said their car wasn’t brand new, Clark said they bought it from a certified dealership, and it still had an extended warranty. He told the advisor about the situation and dropped off the car.

When he got home, his wife said she’d stumbled upon a similar incident involving a Louisiana woman whose mechanic found water in her fuel tank after she refueled at Costco. His wife asked if they might be experiencing the same situation. Although Clark said he also knew of the incident, he didn’t think it would apply to them.

Another alleged case of a pump dispensing water

The dealership advisor later called Clark, and they allegedly told Clark the “bad news.” They allegedly took a sample from the car’s gas tank and learned that it was filled with water. The advisor allegedly added that they needed to drain the fuel line and check for any damage to the car’s engine.

Clark said he would have to pay $1,200 for labor but didn’t include the cost of parts that might need replacement. He continued, “I told this to my wife, and we were both just completely stunned.” Clark told the mechanic to retain the samples and document their findings. Then, they called the undisclosed Costco where his wife allegedly refueled.

“The particular person we spoke to was not very friendly to my wife,” Clark alleged. His wife was allegedly told to go to the store and file out an incident report. She drove Clark’s car, filed the report, and was told a representative would review it. Additionally, Clark said his wife also filed a complaint with the Los Angeles County Department of Agricultural Commissioner/Weights and Measures (ACWM) to have them inspect the gas pump she allegedly used.

Meanwhile, Clark said he filed an insurance claim. “They were generally puzzled by this,” Clark said. Nevertheless, their insurance told him they would investigate but told him not to start any repairs until they’ve given the green light. In the meantime, the family had to wait. Clark shared that not having a vehicle that could fit their four children made the situation tricky. Because the case is unusual, Clark said it took weeks for insurance to investigate and respond.

Costco allegedly closed the case on them

Two weeks later, however, a Costco representative allegedly reached out to them. The representative allegedly claimed that the pumps have sensors to detect water. They allegedly added that employees also perform further checks on the pumps. The representative allegedly promised to review the data for people who filled their tanks at the same premium pump for two days and on the day of the incident.

The next day, the representative allegedly told his wife that they received no other customer complaints during that period. Clark alleged, “At this point, Costco wasn’t claiming any liability in this issue, and they wanted to finish resolving it on their end.” His wife wanted a refund for the gas but was allegedly refused.

Getting the car repaired

Later that day, Clark alleged that another ACWM representative also reached out to his wife. The ACWM representative allegedly said that when they received the report on Friday, they went out to test the Costco pump on Monday. They allegedly found “water and sediment” in the fuel and added that they allegedly shut down the pumps for two days.

Clark sent all the documentation his family gathered regarding the incident but allegedly still did not get a response. It has been ten days without a spare car, and Clark said he had to rent another car so everyone could get where they needed to go. When insurance finally replied, Clark claimed they sent a representative to inspect the car.

“He also confirmed there to be water and sediment in the fuel. And this is a key moment,” Clark said. The mechanics could finally start work on the car. Their insurance apologized for the lengthy investigation and filed the case under comprehensive damage. They were supposed to pay $4,000 in total, but with insurance, Clark estimated they paid only $1,700 for the rental car and the comprehensive deductible.

“Obviously, we were thankful that insurance covered this. But going back to the beginning, it’s just insane, because we bought a product that wasn’t the product advertised, and it damaged our vehicle, and we’re left paying $1,700,” Clark alleged. While car insurance has saved Clark a lot, healthcare insurance is a different story. One mother-to-be claims she has been paying $5,600 per hospital visit despite paying thousands to insurance per month.

The Mary Sue has reached out for comments.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Vanessa Esguerra (She/They) is a staff writer for The Mary Sue. She speaks three languages but still manages to get lost in the subways of Tokyo with her clunky Japanese. Fueled by iced coffee brewed from local cafés, she also regularly covers every possible topic under the sun while queuing for her next match in League of Legends.