Skip to main content

Ohio mother says she watched Cleveland officers fire at her daughter’s car, and now an appeals court says her lawsuit against them can move forward

I can't imagine screaming that it's my daughter's car and watching officers keep shooting at it anyway.

An Ohio appeals court has revived Latrice Carter’s lawsuit against two Cleveland officers who fired at her daughter’s car as she watched, according to Atlanta Black Star. A judge had tossed the case under an Ohio law that often shields police from civil liability. The 8th District Court of Appeals called that dismissal premature as the complaint alleges reckless conduct.

Antwoina Carter called police early on March 17, 2024, after someone who had been threatening her parked outside her home. Officers were talking with her mother outside when Antwoina drove toward them, fleeing a gunman in another vehicle. The police body camera footage shows Latrice shouting, “That’s my daughter’s car,” as officers fired on the approaching car.

The officers kept firing after the car passed them, and Antwoina crashed and died from her injuries. However, investigators reportedly found neither officer fired the fatal shot. The department still suspended Dylan O’Donnell for 15 days and Amanda Rock for 10 days for firing without verifying a visible and immediate threat.

The bullet that killed her came from someone else’s gun

Christopher Stinson, who fired at least 20 shots at Antwoina from another vehicle, received 27 to 32 and a half years in prison after pleading guilty to involuntary manslaughter and other charges. Trinity Ford, the driver, received five to six years after pleading guilty to involuntary manslaughter. Lashuwndre Coleman, the front-seat passenger, received one year of probation for obstructing official business.

Prosecutors said the shooting was unrelated to the threats Antwoina had reported earlier that morning. Authorities have not disclosed a motive. Latrice, who witnessed the shooting, sued both officers in 2025 for negligent infliction of emotional distress.

The appeals court found that the complaint describes more than mere negligence. It pointed to Latrice’s allegation that she “emphatically informed the police officers that they were shooting at her daughter,” according to the ruling. The decision does not settle whether the officers acted recklessly.

The court accepted Latrice’s allegations as true only for this early stage of the lawsuit, and the officers have not been stripped of their immunity. Latrice must still prove her claims as the lawsuit moves forward. Atlanta Black Star’s report did not include a response from the officers or the city.

Ohio sets a high bar before officers lose that protection

Under Ohio’s political subdivision tort liability law, local government employees are generally immune from personal liability. That protection falls away if their actions were malicious, in bad faith, or wanton or reckless. Cleveland police have worked under a federal consent decree since 2015, after a Justice Department investigation found a pattern of excessive force.

The agreement prohibits shooting at moving vehicles. A federal judge recently extended that oversight through 2028. The lawsuit now returns to the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, where Latrice Carter must show the officers acted recklessly to overcome their immunity.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

A girl that has been passionate about anime and gaming ever since she was exposed to it. If she isn't watching anime, she's keeping in touch with the latest news and tech features.