Skip to main content

Kentucky school district gets an anonymous letter about a substitute teacher and a student. Now she pleads guilty to sexually abusing the 16-year-old

Whoever sent that letter may have been the only reason this came out, and I hope every school takes tips like that this seriously.

Mary Hanna Mattingly pleaded guilty to first-degree sexual abuse and possession of matter portraying a sexual performance of a minor this past Friday. The 32-year-old former Bardstown High School teacher broke down in tears during the court hearing, according to WDRB. Her plea agreement calls for a five-year prison sentence, with final sentencing set for January.

The case began with an anonymous letter sent to Bardstown City Schools in March. A written statement from the school district said the letter described alleged inappropriate conduct between a female substitute teacher and a student. Officials placed Mattingly on administrative leave and contacted the police.

The Bardstown Police Department started an investigation after getting the report from the school, and Mattingly was arrested days later over an alleged sexual relationship with a student. Police said she had sexual contact with the 16-year-old. Investigators also said she exchanged nude photos with the minor.

According to the Judge, the abuse happened months before 

The judge confirmed during the hearing that the sexual contact occurred between March 1 and July 31, 2025. That timeline places the abuse well before the anonymous letter reached the district. Bardstown Police Detective Eric Williamson said after the arrest that social media was the main way the two communicated.  

When Mattingly was first arrested, police charged her with first-degree sexual abuse and procuring or promoting the use of a minor by electronic means. However, she ultimately pleaded guilty to the possession charge instead of the electronic means count. Reports on the hearing have not explained why the second charge changed.

Bardstown City Schools later said Mattingly had been fired from her teaching position. She posted a $20,000 bond shortly after her arrest. The five-year term is expected to be formally imposed at sentencing, as the plea agreement still has to go before the judge one final time.

Kentucky law doesn’t let a teacher claim a 16-year-old consented

Kentucky generally sets the age of consent at 16. However, KRS 510.110 makes sexual contact first-degree sexual abuse when the adult holds a position of authority or special trust and the minor is under 18. State law lists teachers and coaches among those positions under KRS 532.045.

A 2013 Kentucky Supreme Court ruling notes that lawmakers added this provision in 2008. One goal was to raise the protected age from 16 to 18 for adults like teachers, who can exert undue influence over students. Justices also found that, in that situation, a minor legally cannot consent.

Both of Mattingly’s convictions are Class D felonies, as KRS 531.335 classifies the possession offense the same way when the minor is under 18. A Class D felony carries one to five years in prison under KRS 532.060, placing her deal at the top of that range.

Mattingly is scheduled to return to court for final sentencing on January 21, 2027, when the five-year term in her plea agreement is expected to be formally imposed.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

A girl that has been passionate about anime and gaming ever since she was exposed to it. If she isn't watching anime, she's keeping in touch with the latest news and tech features.