Joe Manchin Is Now Using the Anti-Abortion Hyde Amendment To Hijack Reconciliation Bill
Purported Democrat Joe Manchin has been one of the major roadblocks standing between his fellow lawmakers and substantive, meaningful legislation. Along with fellow Senator Kyrsten Sinema, Manchin is attempting to nearly singlehandedly derail President Biden’s Build Back Better plan—a massive $3.5 trillion spending package that invests in clean energy, affordable housing, healthcare, childcare, and much more.
Speaking with press today, Joe Manchin called those things “entitlements.”
Manchin says that the very most he could support in this kind of spending package is $1.5 trillion, a figure his colleagues and plenty of others were quick to dismiss as impossibly low, as well as seemingly arbitrary.
“It’s pretty sad if you ask me,” Sen. Mazie Hirono said of Manchin’s proposed price tag.
“I don’t think so,” Sen. Tammy Duckworth said when asked if that number was sufficient.
Democrats plan to discuss at lunch right now.
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) September 30, 2021
Just pointing out that this is completely incoherent.
Manchin really thinks spending $200 billion per year would be “changing our whole society to an entitlement mentality” but spending $150 billion per year does not? https://t.co/38oqjGXP2R
— Judd Legum (@JuddLegum) September 30, 2021
Manchin also stated other, more specific demands, including saying the reconciliation bill is “dead on arrival” if it doesn’t include the horribly outdated and discriminatory Hyde Amendment as it relates to a Medicaid-like program featured in the bill.
The Hyde Amendment bars the use of federal funds in paying for elective abortion care, putting yet another socioeconomic barrier between low-income women and their reproductive autonomy.
As Kylie Cheung explained it on the 43rd anniversary of the amendment:
Hyde is justified as a means to not offend the sensibilities of that small minority of Americans who oppose abortion rights, essentially according this minority with disparate power over the lives and healthcare access of women and pregnant people across the country. Its effects are sexist, racist, and deeply classist, limiting the taxpayer-funded care women and pregnant people receive, despite how we pay the same taxes as men, while also disproportionately harming the low-income women of color who comprise the majority of people who seek abortion care and also are more likely to struggle to afford it.
It’s not surprising to see Manchin defend the Hyde Amendment when most other Democrats have realized it’s past time to throw it out. It is infuriating, though, to see him think he can hijack this legislation to suit the whims of a man who has no business being in the Democratic party in the first place. As an anti-abortion, anti-social safety net politician, his values simply do not align with the party. And yet here he is, holding the party hostage with his entirely Republican demands.
Like listen: Democrats were the Party that enacted most of the “entitlements” Joe Manchin cannot stand…. (Medicare, Medicaid, Disabled benefits, social security etc). He barely fits into the “big tent” because he doesn’t even agree with the foundation of the Party. https://t.co/MW8WspWuic
— Atima Omara (@atima_omara) September 30, 2021
Ultimately, Manchin is being driven by his own conservative anti-abortion hangups as much as he is by his loyalty to corporate lobbyists. And he is very driven by corporate lobbyists.
Do you think Joe Manchin opposes climate spending because he’s concerned about the costs?
Or do you think it’s because he personally founded two coal companies in the 1980s, which are now led by his son, and his entire family’s fortune relies on the fossil fuel industry?
— Robert Reich (@RBReich) September 30, 2021
Manchin and others are focusing on these top line numbers because they are abstractions. It’s a lot easier to say: I support 1.5 trillion but not 2 trillion than saying I don’t want families to have paid leave because private equity managers should keep their tax loophole
— Judd Legum (@JuddLegum) September 30, 2021
Not to mention whatever this is doing for his ego.
Manchin loves this. Let’s be honest. https://t.co/RD1yzLfIVx
— Daniel Strauss (@DanielStrauss4) September 30, 2021
(image: Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
Want more stories like this? Become a subscriber and support the site!
—The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]