‘It definitely feels a little bit shocking’: Woman says a jewelry business added a $350 tip she never approved, then called it a ‘mandatory tip’

The $350 tip is gone from a permanent jewelry bill, and the owners now state no such tip was ever required. According to BroBible, a woman who shared the dispute in a TikTok video was billed $1,430 for a gathering of seven and says she never approved the tip. The business refunded it after she emailed a formal dispute.

She says the receipt lists $1,000 for the work, $80 in sales tax and the $350 tip, with nothing calling the tip mandatory. She had expected about $700, since a price list had been put out at her home and no deposit was taken. “It definitely feels a little bit shocking,” she says. She adds that she would have left a “reasonable tip” if asked.

She called the business, and the person who picked up acted “kind of dodgy,” she says. The jewelry worker called her back within the hour from a personal phone. She says the worker sounded “nervous” and told her the charge was a mandatory tip.

From dispute to refund

The bill also charged for eight people when seven attended. She says the worker offered an immediate refund for that and claimed she believed there were eight. Connectors added to the total as well, which she says became necessary after a chain was cut too short because her wrist was not measured.

A second video says a new receipt arrived after the call that mentioned a “mandatory tip” the first one lacked. She calls that “extremely suspicious” and emailed the business that she was “formally disputing” the payment. The email adds that she would go to her card issuer without written confirmation of a refund. The charge was on a company card for a work-sponsored event.

A day before her deadline, the owners replied with their “sincerest apologies” and a full refund of the tip, with the receipt attached. They stated, “we were unaware of this charge and have never had a policy requiring a $350 travel fee or mandatory gratuity for off-site events.” They added that they are reviewing how such events are handled, and she says this was only their second.

She says the reply tells her the worker “was totally scamming me.” She did not name the business. All details are based on her TikTok videos. According to the IRS, a payment is a tip only if the customer voluntarily decides to pay it and determines the amount. The agency states, “Extra amounts charged to a bill, such as mandatory service charges, are not tips.” That puts a charge like a solo diner’s automatic gratuity in the service charge category as well.

Some customers describe tip fatigue from payment screens. According to Pew Research Center, 72% of US adults oppose businesses including automatic service charges or tips on customers’ bills. Only 10% favor it.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]