Valdosta Publix customer is reportedly accused of stealing a sandwich. Then video shows a man pinning him face down outside with a gun at his back
A man was held face down on the concrete outside a Valdosta, Georgia, Publix after he was accused of stealing a sandwich reportedly worth $6. Footage of the encounter appears to show a man pointing a gun at the customer’s back while another person holds his legs and a woman steps on his foot, according to Atlanta Black Star.
The video, shared by the podcast Digital Push Production and reposted on X, shows the customer pleading with the man holding him down and calling out for his son, who appears to be watching nearby. The man pinning him tells him to stop and relax multiple times, despite the customer not appearing to resist. He also says, “This is so unnecessary,” at one point.
It remains unclear whether the armed man is an off-duty officer or a citizen performing a citizen’s arrest. Georgia repealed its citizen’s arrest law after the murder of Ahmaud Arbery, leaving private citizens with very limited authority to detain others.
No one has publicly shown that the man actually took the sandwich
Much of the anger on social media centers on the level of force used against a man accused of taking a single sandwich. One commenter on the Digital Push Production Facebook page tagged Publix and asked, “How are we to know we are safe from thugs with guns playing police while shopping at your establishments!”
The original poster of the video raised similar concerns, writing, “What resistance was being shown? What immediate threat justified drawing a firearm? And was that level of force proportionate to the situation?” Dozens of commenters have also demanded proof that the customer took anything before he was pinned to the ground.
Georgia lets stores hold suspected shoplifters, but the law limits how much force they can use
Georgia replaced its 1863 citizen’s arrest statute in 2021 with House Bill 479. The new detention law stripped bystanders of the right to detain people, but kept an exception for retail owners and employees who reasonably believe someone shoplifted. However, anyone detaining a suspect under it cannot use force intended or likely to cause great bodily harm or death.
That limit lifts only when the person is acting in self-defense, defending a home, or trying to prevent a forcible felony. Otherwise, detainers may use only reasonable force to hold someone. Police must also release a detained person and their belongings if they do not arrive within a reasonable time.
Off-duty officers operate under separate rules. While officers can make arrests without a warrant if they see a crime happen, the rules for off-duty personnel are specific and often depend on the situation. However, the armed man’s identity and any link to Publix or law enforcement have not been made public.
Any criminal case over the alleged Publix theft would likely be a misdemeanor, as Georgia law treats shoplifting of $500 or less as a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
