Cops call Tennessee woman to inform her stolen license plate was recovered—but she never reported any theft: ‘It’s on my BMW sitting in the driveway’
I’d march to the station to get the full story immediately.
Receiving an unexpected voicemail from local law enforcement is enough to make anyone’s stomach drop. Even if they explicitly promise you aren’t under investigation, you cannot sit straight before you call them back. But when Tennessee musician Taylor Austin Dye (@tayloraustindye) made the callback, she found herself into an administrative twilight zone involving a phantom license plate theft.
In a viral TikTok Video viewed over 31,000 times, Dye recounted the baffling conversation that ensued when she allegedly returned a missed call from the police. According to her, an officer claimed to have located her missing license plate that was never actually missing. And just like that, the follow-up dissolved into an unresolved mystery about how authorities “recovered” an item currently sitting outside her front door.
Dye admitted she will likely never receive closure regarding whose license plate was actually flagged. Nor will she know what piece of metal the department had bagged into evidence. In her caption, she questioned how she always ends up in such strange situations. But at least her BMW and its plate are intact!
An unexpected police voicemail claimed to locate Dye’s stolen license plate
The confusion began when Dye reportedly noticed a missed phone call paired with an urgent voicemail from a local police officer. Though the deputy assured her that she hadn’t broken any laws, he requested an immediate callback to discuss an open matter. “Officer left me a voicemail, said, ‘You’re not in trouble, but please call me back.’ Sh*t, I’m in trouble,” Dye thought.
Dialing the police station back, Dye was patched through to the officer, confirming the deputy was at least real. He then allegedly stated he was calling to follow up on her “stolen license plate.” Upon hearing this, she was immediately spooked by the prospect of overnight vehicle tampering. So, she stepped out to her driveway to inspect her BMW, only to find her registration tags firmly bolted in place right where she left them.
The conversation took a turn for the surreal when the officer began reciting her alphanumeric combination digit by digit. “He said, ‘Is this your license plate?’ I said, ‘Yeah, it’s on my car. It’s on my BMW sitting in the driveway.’ And he said, ‘So it’s not stolen?’ I said, ‘No,’” Dye recalled the conversation.
The cop allegedly claimed to have her license plate in physical custody
After Dye confirmed that the number matched her vehicle, the officer pressed further. He reportedly asked Dye why she had filed a police report claiming the tags had been stolen. To this, Dye clarified that she had never called 911 or reported any property crime. Completely deadpan, the officer responded, “Well, we found it.”
All this while, Dye was standing in her driveway and staring directly at her vehicle’s license plate. So, she pushed back on the officer’s claim, pointing out that recovering an item that was currently in her sight was physically impossible. Confronted with the paradox, the officer allegedly offered a brief, bewildered, “Huh. That’s strange,” before abruptly concluding the call.
While the brief exchange sounds like an absurd comedic sketch, duplicate registration anomalies happen more often than drivers realize. Criminals frequently manufacture counterfeit plates using real registration digits belonging to identical makes and models to mask stolen vehicles.
Or, a single misplaced letter or digit keyed into an incident report can also accidentally link a recovered vehicle’s tag to an entirely uninvolved citizen’s VIN. However, if the police really had Dye’s exact license plate physically, it was probably a counterfeit. But the mix-up by the police left Dye in a Limbo, wondering what really happened.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
