Taco Bell customer expects $9.39 back after paying cash, but says employee refused to hand over any coins: ‘It’s the principle of the thing’
The customer was willing to give up four pennies, but says the cashier wouldn't hand over any coins at all.
A Taco Bell customer says she was supposed to receive $9.39 in change after paying cash, but the employee handed her only the bills. When Holley asked about the missing 39 cents, the worker reportedly blamed the nationwide penny shortage. Even after she offered to accept just 35 cents, she says the employee refused to give her any coins.
In a Facebook post describing the encounter, Holley questioned why a shortage of pennies meant customers couldn’t receive nickels, dimes, or quarters either. She also wondered how much Taco Bell could potentially keep if other locations followed the same practice. “It’s not the 38 cents it’s the principle of the thing,” she wrote, adding that she wouldn’t return.
The interaction has not been independently verified, and Holley did not identify which Taco Bell location she visited. However, the U.S. Treasury’s guidance on penny shortages recommends rounding cash transactions to the nearest nickel when exact change isn’t available, rather than withholding all coin change.
The customer offered to take less change, but says the worker still refused
According to Holley, the cashier explained the missing money by saying Taco Bell no longer gives change because of the penny shortage. Holley then asked for 35 cents, apparently willing to forgo the four pennies she was owed. The employee reportedly responded that the restaurant wasn’t giving out coins at all.
Other Taco Bell customers have reported disputes over missing coin change. In one earlier incident, a woman said employees gave her $9.55 instead of the $9.74 she was owed, explaining that they had run out of certain coins. Holley’s complaint raises a similar question about what happens when a restaurant doesn’t have the correct change available.
Facebook commenters largely questioned the cashier’s explanation. Kathy Mara suggested the employee might have misunderstood the instructions, noting that other businesses still return the nickel and dime portions of customers’ change. Theresa Banning Green said her Circle K location rounds 39 cents up to 40 cents, while other commenters encouraged Holley to contact management.
Not everyone accepted her account, though. One commenter questioned whether the incident happened at all, while others wondered whether the employee had simply misunderstood the restaurant’s policy. No evidence establishes that Taco Bell has instructed its locations to withhold all coin change.
What does the penny shortage actually mean for cash customers?
The U.S. Mint stopped producing circulating pennies on November 12, 2025, after production costs reached 3.69 cents per coin. Existing pennies remain legal tender, but some businesses have struggled to maintain supplies for cash transactions.
According to the U.S. Treasury’s guidance, businesses can round cash totals to the nearest five cents when pennies aren’t available. Amounts ending in eight or nine cents generally round up, while those ending in six or seven cents round down. For Holley’s $9.39 in change, that would mean receiving $9.40 under the recommended approach.
The issue has already frustrated customers at other chains, including a Subway customer who disputed missing pennies. In that case, the customer argued that a store’s inability to provide exact change shouldn’t leave shoppers short.
Treasury guidance is not a blanket federal mandate, and states may establish different rounding requirements. Without knowing which Taco Bell Holley visited, it’s unclear what local rules applied or whether the employee followed company policy. Still, the shortage of one-cent coins does not explain why she allegedly received none of the 39 cents owed.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
