Police say a Santa Cruz surfing legend was tortured for his bank PINs in Costa Rica. Now his girlfriend, first called a survivor, has been arrested
I’d be going back over every interview she gave after that night.

The girlfriend of Santa Cruz surfing legend Kurt Van Dyke has been arrested in Costa Rica, as police suspect she let in the men who allegedly tortured him for his bank PINs. Costa Rican police arrested 31-year-old Arroyo and a 34-year-old man identified as Gutiérrez nearly nine months after the killing, according to The New York Post.
Arroyo was initially treated as a survivor after telling police she was tied up during a home invasion by armed intruders in Hone Creek. Investigators now believe her account was false, as they suspect it was staged to hide her alleged involvement. Vladimir Muñoz, acting deputy general director of the Judicial Investigation Agency, said investigators believe she was directly involved.
Police reconstruction indicates that Gutiérrez entered the house with two other men to obtain the PINs for Kurt Van Dyke’s bank cards. When Kurt Van Dyke refused to give up the codes, the men allegedly beat and tortured him. Investigators also believe the group staged the theft of Arroyo’s car to make the incident look like a robbery.
Investigators think the stolen car was part of the setup
Kurt Van Dyke was found under a bed with apparent knife wounds and signs of suffocation. The car was later found in the country’s Atlantic region with no damage, and investigators appear to view that as a sign the theft was faked to point suspicion away from Arroyo. However, neither suspect has been formally charged so far.
In the days after the killing, Arroyo told Costa Rican outlets she had been in the shower when the men entered. A preliminary report from the agency listed asphyxiation as the cause of death, and a knife was reportedly found beside the body. Muñoz has also said the suspects allegedly wanted PINs for cards linked to the Hotel Puerto Viejo.
Agents carried out three raids in Pocora and Astúa Pirie near Guápiles, and both suspects reportedly live in Pocora. During the raids, agents seized cellphones and the vehicle that Gutiérrez and the two other men allegedly used to travel to the house. The search for those two remaining suspects continues, as they have not been identified.
Kurt Van Dyke was the son of Northern California surfing pioneers Gene and Betty Van Dyke. He moved to Costa Rica’s Caribbean coast decades ago to ride the Salsa Brava break and later owned the hotel. The family was “just glad that it’s over,” his brother Peter Van Dyke told the outlet, adding that court cases are still to come.
Prosecutors in Costa Rica now have to decide whether to charge them
In Costa Rica, the Public Ministry handles prosecutions under the country’s Criminal Procedure Code, and it can ask a judge to hold suspects in preventive detention. That detention can generally last up to 12 months, with a possible one-year extension, according to a 2016 report from the country’s ombudsman office. However, cases declared complex can carry longer limits.
Investigators are still trying to identify the two other men believed to have entered Kurt Van Dyke’s house. At the same time, the Public Ministry is expected to decide whether Arroyo and Gutiérrez will face charges.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]