Ohio neighbor says man visited their home to give a housewarming gift. Then they discover the item was allegedly used in a crime
Among the festive gifts was allegedly a gun.

An Ohio man was accused of killing his girlfriend before allegedly paying his neighbor a visit to hand over a couple of items, one of which investigators believe was the murder weapon. 51-year-old Darwin Malcolm had been indicted on 12 counts, including tampering with evidence, murder, and gross abuse of a corpse in connection with the death of 43-year-old Samantha Kelly, by a grand jury on Monday, Nov. 16.
Middletown Division of Police officers responded to a welfare check at a unit in Tytus Suites on the 4000 block of Tytus Avenue, Middletown, around 4:30 p.m. on Thursday, Nov. 5, according to WLWT. Officers arrived and discovered the body of a woman inside a Chevy Tahoe, whom they described as having “sustained fatal injuries.” The Butler County Coroner later identified the victim as Kelly and said she died from a gunshot wound, as reported by Local 12.
Malcolm was arrested the same day and allegedly told investigators that he shot Kelly, whom he was living with at the time, before he placed her body in the back of his vehicle. After the killing, he said he went to his neighbor’s house and gave them several items in a bag as “housewarming gifts,” including a gun wrapped in a towel. He then disposed of items such as a bloody towel and a shell casing, among others, in the apartment complex’s dumpster, according to court documents.
Ohio neighbor says there was another couple
“It was like a red grill, a little small deep fryer, a little small Christmas tree, and some Christmas lights,” the neighbor told WLWT. “And in the midst of all that, there was the gun wrapped up.”
The neighbor said they often heard arguments coming from the couple’s unit, although they were not sure if it was Malcolm and Kelly arguing, as they claimed another couple, said to be in their twenties, were living in the unit as well. The neighbor did not hear a gunshot but recalled seeing Kelly looking “agitated” when she entered their unit that day.
According to the owners of Tytus Suites, who declined to be identified, Kelly had been living at the property for several weeks. Malcolm reportedly moved in with Kelly a few days after she settled into the new place. However, the owners had not confirmed the neighbor’s claim about the second couple.
The alleged murder and concealment were said to have been caught on video, according to prosecutors. The video allegedly showed Malcolm dragging Kelly’s body by her hair to his vehicle before he shoved her into the trunk. Journal-News reported that Kelly’s body was also covered with a blanket.
Malcolm pled not guilty to all counts and reportedly waived his right to a quick trial, with a judge setting his bond at $1.5 million. His next court date is slated for Jan. 11, 2027.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]