Skip to main content

Minnesota man is convicted of first-degree murder for killing his 14-year-old ‘ex-girlfriend’ after asking her to meet him at their usual park bench

Knowing she went to meet him at their usual bench, trusting him, is the part I can't get past.

A Minnesota judge has found Isaac Arndt guilty of first-degree premeditated murder in the killing of his 14-year-old ex-girlfriend, Jaelyn Walker, according to Law & Crime. Judge Tammy Merkins also convicted Arndt, now 19, on two counts of second-degree murder. Walker’s mother, Amanda Gullekson, welcomed the verdict but said Arndt showed no remorse in court as it was read.

Prosecutors argued Arndt, then 18, asked Walker to meet at their usual bench in Moorhead’s Gooseberry Park in August 2024. Chief Assistant Clay County Attorney Pam Foss wrote that he “played on the emotions of a lovesick teenager” to lure her into secluded woods by the Red River. Prosecutors said the teenage girl was stabbed to death in the wooded area that evening.

Gullekson shouted “we did it” as she left court, where supporters had packed the gallery in shirts showing Jaelyn’s face inside a heart. She said she was relieved he would never be on the streets to hurt anyone again. Outside the courthouse, the family released balloons, saying they were “retiring the red” as justice had been served.

Arndt reportedly walked into a police station that night with a very different story

Isaac Arndt initially tried to shift the blame, walking into the Clay County Law Enforcement Center around 11 p.m. to report an assault. He claimed an unknown man had followed and attacked them at Gooseberry Park, and he showed police cuts on his fingers. About 90 minutes later, Gullekson called Moorhead police to report her daughter missing.

His account changed after detectives tracked him down at a Fargo hospital. Arndt eventually admitted to the relationship and to killing Walker, though he claimed she had hit and kicked him first. Investigators said he then moved her body toward the river before leaving the park.

Investigators found bloody socks and a towel hidden in a kitchen cupboard at his Fargo apartment, plus bloodstained toilet paper in the bathroom. Texts on Walker’s phone showed the pair had agreed to meet around 7:30 p.m. Surveillance video from a nearby home captured him leaving the wooded area on a scooter shortly after the attack.

Prosecutors argued the killing was planned, as Arndt brought a knife, extra clothing, and disposable gloves from home. They said he used a different phone number to arrange the meeting and had told two people he wanted to end contact with Walker. However, his defense argued he acted on impulse and sought lesser second-degree charges, which Merkins rejected.

Minnesota law leaves very little to decide at sentencing

Under Minnesota’s heinous crimes statute, an adult convicted of premeditated first-degree murder must be sentenced to life without the possibility of release. A 2023 change spares offenders who were under 18 at the time, who receive a standard life term instead. However, Arndt was 18 when he killed Walker, so the mandatory sentence is expected to apply.

Her grandfather, Doug Gullekson, remembered Jaelyn as a free spirit who was set to start high school in Moorhead that fall. Physical dating violence is not unusual among teenagers, as about one in 12 U.S. high schoolers who dated reported it in a 2021 CDC survey. Teens and parents can reach the National Teen Dating Abuse Helpline at 1-866-331-9474.

Merkins scheduled Arndt’s sentencing for Jan. 20, when Walker’s family plans to read victim impact statements and play a video honoring Jaelyn’s life.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

A girl that has been passionate about anime and gaming ever since she was exposed to it. If she isn't watching anime, she's keeping in touch with the latest news and tech features.