Georgia officer who shot a donkey named HeeHaw is back on duty ‘effective immediately,’ even though state investigators say he broke the law
Two agencies watched the same night and reached opposite answers, and I'd want a lot more than a letter if HeeHaw were mine.

Officer Trenton Garner is back on full duty with the Cedartown Police Department. The decision to reinstate him came weeks after authorities decided not to pursue criminal charges for the death of a donkey named HeeHaw. City Manager Edward Guzman and Police Chief James Newsome signed a letter stating Garner’s return was effective immediately, according to CBS.
Garner shot the pet donkey shortly after midnight in late August while officers using a police dog and a drone searched a Polk County pasture for a missing 12-year-old girl. Body camera footage shows HeeHaw moving toward the officers, who are seen backing away from the animal. Police said the girl was later found at a church near the pasture.
Investigators with the Georgia Department of Agriculture believed there was evidence to support criminal charges against Garner. However, Tallapoosa Judicial Circuit District Attorney Jaeson Smith disagreed with their assessment, finding that Garner reasonably acted to protect another officer. Smith wrote that Garner’s actions do not sustain criminal liability and claimed the state’s assessment omitted important information.
The officers tried to scare HeeHaw off before Garner fired
His incident report says another officer used a Taser’s electrical arc to scare the donkey off, but HeeHaw kept approaching. He said he fired his weapon once, which caused the donkey to turn, move uphill, and collapse. Garner told dispatch that a firearm was discharged at a donkey as it was trying to attack them in the pasture.
The donkey’s owner, Hannah Michelle Israel, has since filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against Garner demanding $1 million. She alleges that officers entered her fenced pasture without a warrant or permission and that Garner shot HeeHaw without provocation. Garner has asked a judge to drop the case entirely, as his defense argues he is protected by qualified immunity.
That doctrine shields police from lawsuits for money over actions taken in the course of their job. Officers generally keep that protection unless they violated a clearly established statutory or constitutional right, per Cornell’s Legal Information Institute. Courts are expected to settle the question early, as the doctrine is meant to spare officials from going to trial.
Donkeys have a reputation for standing their ground
Donkeys can show strong territorial behavior, and the instinct is reliable enough that farmers in many countries use them to guard sheep and goats against dogs and coyotes, according to The Donkey Sanctuary. In the wild, the charity says, the bray appears to be used mainly by male donkeys as a territorial display.
Israel has said HeeHaw was bottle-raised and was only doing what donkeys do when he brayed at the officers. State investigators appeared to side with her, finding the donkey seemed to be approaching in a friendly, non-aggressive manner, according to the AJC.
Smith read the night differently, as his report reportedly cited a neighbor who claimed HeeHaw had attacked him before. He also said officers had legal authority to enter the pasture during the search. However, Israel’s lawsuit argues no emergency justified entering without a warrant.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]