Michigan woman accidentally brushes her butt against a girl in the NYC subway, then glances over her phone and reads something infuriating
She made the right decision to ignore it.
Squeezing into a crowded subway during rush hour mandates abandoning all expectations of personal space. But for Michigan native Ava Manelis (@ava.manelis), an unavoidable brush on a jam-packed New York City commute allegedly escalated into a petty text-message showdown.
The NYC subway is known for its bizarre commuters. In a candid TikTok storytime, Manelis shared the details of her awkward encounter aboard the NYC subway during an oppressive summer heatwave. While it was a standard case of commuter crowding for her, the girl sitting near her refused to take it as that. She allegedly glared at Manelis with pure hatred for accidentally backing up into her hand on the armrest.
The passenger didn’t stop there. When Manelis stared down at her screen, she was reportedly firing off passive-aggressive insults about her to a friend. But major city lines during peak evening hours are designed for capacity. Which means that incidental brushing against strangers is structurally unavoidable. So, Manelis announced boldly, “If you don’t want to be touched by people, don’t take the subway. Point blank.”
A rush-hour heatwave brought chaos to the NYC subway
The incident reportedly unfolded right around 5:00 PM as Manelis hopped aboard the notorious 6 train to head to class. The evening rush was in full swing and temperatures soared outside. Naturally, the subway was packed shoulder-to-shoulder with sweaty, exhausted commuters trying to make their way home.
Finding zero breathing room, Manelis stood near the seated rows. She wedged herself as close to the partition as possible to make space for passengers pressing through the sliding doors. But as the train rattled along the tracks, her backside lightly brushed against the forearm of a seated woman resting on the edge of the seat divider.
Instead of brushing off the accidental bump as standard rush-hour contact, the seated woman allegedly looked up and delivered a glare of pure, unadulterated venom. “She looks at me, when I accidentally brush up on her—my butt to her arm—like I just killed her firstborn son in front of her.”
Recognizing that neither of them had anywhere else to shift, Manelis mentally dismissed the dramatic reaction. She reminded herself that close quarters are simply part of the transit contract. However, the real surprise arrived moments later when Manelis glanced down at the seated woman’s phone out of boredom.
Manelis read an infuriating text on the woman’s screen
The passenger was allegedly typing away on her smartphone, firing off a complaint message to a friend about the commute. Peeking over her shoulder, Manelis caught the message in real time: “This stupid girl keeps bumping into me.” Needless to say, she was stunned by the brazen hostility.
But Manelis held her tongue. She noted that if someone cannot handle incidental contact on an overcrowded train, public transit isn’t the commute for them. Truthfully, public transit systems function entirely on collective compromise. Expecting private bubbles inside packed cars isn’t practical and always leads to commuter rage.
Manelis laughed off the drama while wrapping up her recap. She concluded that while neither she nor the complaining rider may be lifelong New Yorkers, handling the daily transit chaos requires a thicker skin. She also made it a point for her viewers that if you can’t stand strangers sharing your air on a busy transit line, stay off the tracks and take a cab instead.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
