Skip to main content

Man back to dating after an 8-year relationship says he hit it off with his match on the phone, then he got to her place: ‘My heart sank’

He says it is “easier to get ghosted or receive this kind of text than it is to send it.”

A Reddit user says he broke things off with a woman he matched with following their first meeting, claiming she looked different from her photos. According to The Daily Dot, he described the experience in a subreddit post. A relationship of eight years ended about five months ago, he says, and he had felt no real bond with anyone since then until the match.

The two matched on a dating app and “instantly hit it off,” he says. They had “a lot in common” and “good chemistry over the phone” before planning a date. Excited that it “might actually go past a first date,” he adds that her expectations were “pretty high” beforehand, and he tried to slow them down.

Upon reaching her place, he writes, “my heart sank,” because she “looked absolutely nothing like her pictures.” His estimate is that she was “probably a good 150 pounds heavier and clearly older than she was leading off to be.” Later, he says, he found the pictures were more than five to seven years old.

He says sending the text was harder than being ghosted

Calling use of old pictures “extremely disingenuous,” he says he has no issue with “someone being bigger.” The choice suggested low confidence to him and made him wonder “what else are you unhappy about and may lie about in the future.” Still, he says he stayed because “you never know we may still hit it off despite this poor start,” but later felt they were not compatible.

Afterward, he sent her a text saying “I don’t think this will work out.” Feeling “horrible” about it, he says, since she kept telling him the date was going well and that she thought she had found her “forever person.” She also told him that after he left, he adds, she “went to bed with a smile on her face for the first time a long time.”

In the post, he also writes that “it’s easier to get ghosted or receive this kind of text than it is to send it,” and that he is “normally on the other side of this conversation.” It was the first time dating had gone badly since his relationship ended, he says. All details are based on the Reddit user’s account in the post, which presents only his version of events.

Online dating is common, though users report concerns about honesty. Pew Research Center reported in a 2019 survey that about three in ten U.S. adults had used a dating site or app. Roughly 71% of online daters described lying to appear more desirable as widespread among users. Dating app photos that do not match a date in person have prompted similar posts, such as one from a woman who says her first date was a catfish.

Ghosting is the other end of the situation he describes, as when a woman says a Hinge match ghosted her after their date she thought had gone well. In the Reddit user’s account, he sent a text rather than going silent. Security guidance describes catfishing as a scam built on a fake online identity. Norton lists warning signs such as avoiding video calls, a minimal social media presence and photos that appear stolen.

It advises requesting a live video call and running a reverse image search to check whether someone’s photos appear elsewhere.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Anshu Thakur is a writer who covers culture and trending stories across the internet. Her work focuses on the intersection of internet trends, entertainment, and fan reactions.