Today in Not Understanding Copyright: HBO Flags VLC Player in DMCA Takedown Request
In a related story, I'm planning to sue Weather.com because it might rain today.
Ahh, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. How often are you a source of anger and confusion for all of us! Under this well-meaning but boneheaded law, copyright holders send literally millions of takedown requests to Google every single month — 14,855,269 URLs during the past month alone, if you’re counting. Predictably, that includes plenty of totally illegitimate claims requesting the removal of content that doesn’t infringe anything. Take HBO’s recent request, for example, for Google to take down a URL linking not to an HBO show, but to the perfectly legal open source VLC Player program. Yes, just the level of professionalism and attention to detail we’ve come to expect from copyright claims on the Internet!
First discovered by TorrentFreak the VLC-related link in question came from a download via Torrent Patrol. For those of you who aren’t familiar, VLC is an open source software that’s free to use — and even if it weren’t, HBO doesn’t own it or own any content that’s infringed by its existence.
We’ve seen a string of really ridiculous lawsuits threats recently: from Putt Putt suing Minecraft because some users created Putt-Putt themed content, to a guy suing Apple because the internet has porn on it. This takedown request is similarly troubling in the way that it targets something that has literally no involvement in the problem at hand. Sure, some people may or may not use VLC to play their torrented episodes of Game of Thrones — in fact, it’s a great option for just that — but it’s not VLC that’s the problem there; it’s the original material that’s being torrented.
Given most copyright holders’ track record with using automated programs to weed out piracy, however, this looks like less a calculated move on HBO’s part and more of a fluke error the company couldn’t be bothered to correct. After all, this is the same company that once requested that Google take down their own website, and Torrent Freak also found links to many non-HBO-owned properties in the same list that mentioned VLC, including Naruto, free Java applets, and porn. Lots and lots of porn. Conscious decision or not, however, it’s clear that HBO has made a mistake here, and that the DCMA as it currently functions — or doesn’t function, really — has a lot to answer for.
Until we stop seeing ludicrous takedown requests like this, it’s hard for anyone — consumers or media companies — to take DMCA seriously as a solution to piracy. You know what would be a solution to piracy, HBO? The a la carte digital subscription that so many of the folks currently torrenting your content would happily pay for. It’s just possible that if you spent more time figuring out a way to make that work and less time issuing bogus DMCA takedowns, everyone involved would be better off. Just a thought.
- Movie studios get circular, ask Google to take down their own DMCA takedown requests
- WordPress takes down original blog posts after bogus DMCA claim by content thief
- 1.5 million educational blogs taken down over single DMCA notice from textbook publisher
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]