Skip to main content

Florida plastic surgeon is sentenced to death for killing the lawyer in his lawsuit, then calling into a hearing the lawyer never joined

He killed the lawyer, then called into the hearing from the parking lot.

A Florida plastic surgeon was sentenced to death for murdering a lawyer who represented his former employer and colleagues in a lawsuit he had filed against them. Tomasz Kosowski, 47, received the sentence on November 20 from Pinellas County Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone, who found him guilty of first-degree murder in September, according to ABC News.

Steven Cozzi, 41, disappeared from his law office in Largo on March 21, 2023. Prosecutors said Kosowski killed him in the building’s bathroom, removed his body in a wagon and disposed of it in a dumpster in Collier County. Cozzi’s body was never found.

Kosowski represented himself and waived a jury for both the trial and sentencing. At sentencing, Bulone said the reasons for a death sentence outweighed the mitigating evidence and that Kosowski “has forfeited his right to live.”

Prosecutors laid out a trail of video, blood and phone records

Witnesses testified that Kosowski confronted Cozzi in the office bathroom during a January 2023 deposition, called him a “scumbag” and told him he would win in the end, according to FOX 13. On the morning Cozzi disappeared, his phone, keys and wallet were left on his desk, and colleagues testified he appeared to be in the middle of writing an email.

Prosecutors said surveillance footage showed someone entering the building with a large box that morning, and later showed a man they identified as Kosowski pulling a heavy wagon to a pickup truck and struggling to load it. Before leaving the parking lot, Kosowski called into a scheduled hearing in the civil lawsuit, prosecutors said. Cozzi never joined the call.

Investigators found Cozzi’s blood in the law office bathroom, the truck and Kosowski’s garage, and Kosowski’s blood was also found in the bathroom. Cellphone records placed Kosowski near the office when Cozzi disappeared and later near a dumpster in Collier County.

The judge rejected one argument for the death penalty

Bulone found that prosecutors proved two aggravating factors: that the murder was committed for financial gain and that it was “cold, calculated and premeditated.” Assistant State Attorney Nathan Vonderheide said in his closing argument that Kosowski “had the obsession, and he prepared, and he had a plan.”

The judge did not find that the murder was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel, a third factor prosecutors had raised. Kosowski chose not to present evidence supporting a life sentence, so the court appointed independent special counsel John Nohlgren, whose sentencing memorandum laid out Kosowski’s background, including his medical career, his conduct in jail and his lack of prior arrests or convictions.

During the trial, Kosowski argued that it was “impossible” for him to have committed the crime as prosecutors described and questioned whether Cozzi died that day, pointing to transactions on his credit card in the weeks afterward. “Reasonable doubt exists in droves in this case,” he said.

After the verdict, Cozzi’s husband, Michael Montgomery, told the court, “The most unbearable part is that we were never able to bring Steven home.” He asked the court to remember Cozzi for his love of running and cooking, his passion for the law and the people who loved him.

Florida law requires the Florida Supreme Court to automatically review death sentences, though death sentences can take years to carry out. A public defender was appointed for Kosowski’s appeal on the day he was sentenced, according to the court docket.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Sky Blanton is a writer who has always had a soft spot for the stories people can’t stop talking about. Whether it’s a new movie, a TV obsession, or the latest pop culture debate, she loves digging into the why behind what captures an audience’s attention. Her work covers entertainment news, film and television, and the ever-changing conversations happening across fandoms.