Skip to main content

Andrew Tate’s attorney leans on tried and tested misogynistic defense to counter new bestiality allegations

‘Supermodels pursue him.’

The legal situation surrounding Andrew Tate and his brother Tristan has taken a bizarre turn. British prosecutors recently filed documents containing disturbing claims about material allegedly linked to Andrew. These files, which were part of an effort to extradite the brothers from the United States, allege that authorities found extreme pornography related to minors and bestiality on an electronic device. 

According to Reality Tea, the accusations specifically mention content involving a horse and an eel. They also allege the possession of other extreme material and images involving a minor. Andrew Tate’s attorney, Joseph McBride, has strongly rejected these latest claims. He spoke to TMZ to push back against the narrative being presented by U.K. authorities. 

McBride insists that the evidence does not show that Tate ever watched or shared the material in question. He also claimed that Tate responded to the specific allegation regarding the horse with a joke that fits his public persona. According to McBride, Tate told him, “This is horses—.” The attorney added that Tate “of course has a sense of humor about this stuff.”

McBride rejected the idea that Tate has any interest in bestiality

He described his client as a “multiple-woman guy” and claimed that supermodels pursue him. The defense attorney offered a specific explanation for the videos cited by the prosecutors. He stated that police found a phone during a raid at a UK house many years ago. According to McBride, the device was later examined by authorities. He claims the phone contained a group chat involving several mixed martial arts fighters.

McBride said the fighters were sharing videos intended to shock and disgust one another. He even noted that the group chat included videos of soldiers during the war with ISIS. The attorney said one video showed “some guy banging a horse.” 

He insisted that prosecutors have no proof that Tate sent, watched, or appeared in any of those videos. McBride also pointed out that police no longer possess the physical phone. He said they only produced a report about the alleged contents of the device.

This legal battle is happening while the brothers remain in Miami

Federal agents arrested Andrew and Tristan Tate in July after UK authorities sought them. The UK formally requested their extradition on October 5. The brothers continue to fight the request while held in federal custody. The charges they face in the UK are quite serious. They include rape, assault, human trafficking, and controlling prostitution for gain.

The defense team is currently working on multiple fronts to change the status of the brothers. Andrew and Tristan recently asked a federal judge to grant them bail. They filed a petition on Wednesday seeking their immediate release on bond. The brothers argue that prosecutors have not shown they pose a flight risk. They also assert they are not a danger to the community.

In their filing, the brothers pointed to their lack of criminal history in the United States. They also cited their previous conduct during legal proceedings in Romania. They claimed they followed all court-imposed release conditions while in that country. Their attorneys are challenging the usual presumption against bail in extradition cases. 

They argue that courts have relied on an incorrect interpretation of a 123-year-old Supreme Court ruling. The defense team has proposed alternatives to detention. These include options like electronic monitoring or home detention to ensure the brothers appear at future proceedings.

The Tate brothers are also focusing on their current detention conditions

Their attorneys stated that authorities have held them in the Special Housing Unit at the Federal Detention Center in Miami. The defense claims the brothers receive limited recreation time. They also report that the two only get one phone call per month. The attorneys cited no television access and restricted commissary privileges as further issues.

The petition also argued that the brothers have traveled internationally in the past without ever fleeing. They claim authorities did not need to arrest them urgently in the United States. The Crown Prosecution Service recently announced 32 additional charges against Andrew. These include rape, trafficking for sexual exploitation, and assault. They also involve offenses related to indecent images of a child and extreme pornography. 

Tristan faces six additional charges. These include rape, sexual assault, and trafficking for sexual exploitation. Both brothers have denied all of the allegations brought against them. The court has not yet scheduled an extradition hearing for the case. 

For now, Andrew and Tristan remain in custody in Miami. They are continuing to fight the extradition request while awaiting a decision from the court. It is a complex legal situation with many moving parts. 

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

A newsroom lifer who has wrestled countless stories into submission, Terrina is drawn to politics, culture, animals, music and offbeat tales. Fueled by unending curiosity and masterful exasperation, her power tools of choice are wit, warmth and precision.