Popular Science Picks the 2012 Movie With the Sloppiest Science
by Rebecca Pahle | 2:00 pm, January 2nd, 2013
Science in sci-fi movies is rarely all that accurate. We get that. It’s OK. Space battles wouldn’t be nearly so visually interesting if there weren’t any impossible explosions taking place in a vacuum. But some movies take their disregard for the basic principles of science to the next level. And according to Popular Science, the worst perpetrator from 2012 is…
Prometheus. Never saw that coming, did you?
The crew at PopSci called Ridley Scott‘s Alien prequel (hey, screenwriter Damon Lindelof gave the go-ahead on calling it a prequel, so darnit, that’s what I’m doing) “a funhouse of ridiculous and horribly distracting violations of science–and common sense.”
Among those violations: Scientists who take off their helmets within minutes of setting foot on an alien planet, the crew of a high-tech mission never having met before the start of said mission, and a super-sophisticated android who can’t tell time (“when asked how long the mission has lasted, [David] says, “2 years, 4 months, 18 days, 36 hours, 15 minutes,” not “2 years, 4 months,19 days, 12 hours and 15 minutes”).
“Just about the only thing that Scott got right with Prometheus was the organizational ineptitude of the mission, which was essentially a doomed-to-catastrophically-fail season of Big Brother on an alien world.”
The others on the list, from least-to-most offensive, are: The Amazing Spider-Man, Looper, Skyfall, The Avengers, The Dark Knight Rises, and Total Recall.