What's with the name?
Allow us to explain.
by Susana Polo | 10:13 am, February 25th, 2013
art | Pixar | Star Trek
WTF is up with Sulu? He looks like he is genuinely yellow in colour. Unless this is supposed to be re-imagining Sulu as an alien, literally yellow skin on the only asian cast member strikes me as kind of really racist. Or, actually erasing the only asian cast member in favour of an alien, while leaving the white cast intact.
It is pretty clear that he’s using actual Pixar character models for most of these, but he really messed up the klingon – look at the colour of the face and the neck.
I am totally disappointed in you for not at all pointing out obvious yellow face on Sulu.
Apparently, Sulu has jaundice.
I… Why is Sulu neon yellow and so… Toothy? To be honest, it’s really creeping me out. It’s like he’s from a cartoon during the Yellow Peril era. Really jarring considering all of the other human characters have smooth, nuanced skintones.
Most of these are lovely, but I am sad that he has trouble with the all important skin-tone (specifically on Sulu, but Spock & the Klingon are a little off as well.) Doesn’t Pixar have any Asian characters for him to draw from?
The artist is actually colorblind. He simply uses the eyedropper tool off of photographs to get the skin tones. I guess he just picked from a lousy area that time.
Sulu looks like a racist caricature of Ben Chang… And I prefer Random Klingon when he was Random Scotsman.
Russell from Up is the only one I can think of.
The artist is colorblind. Literally.
Does that mean it’s OK to make yellow face? Why didn’t anyone else point that out before publicizing it
What the hell happened with Sulu? All the others are clearly recognizable as pixar characters with some features added/removed but Sulu is just some funky mish-mash in yellowface :(
Yellowface Sulu. Boo.
And has been eating cheetos.
That explains why Spock is green.
Wow, he sounds like a defensive asshole. “Hey, I got it strait [sic] from the source! Hey, I’m an artist, that’s why I can’t spell!”
Also, he may be colorblind, but I’m not buying the “purely by accident” line. You mean he impeccably colored every human cast member, but somehow just matt-painted Sulu’s skin in yellow “straight from the source”, despite the fact that a quick search of Sulu pulls up numerous photos lacking high yellow pigmentation, along with getting subtle hair highlights down to the detail?
Since everyone else has mentioned Sulu, I’ll wonder why McCoy looks like a shaved ape.
Yeah, that was the first thing I noticed about Sulu too… yellow face? Really?
And that sure as hell was not much of an apology… blaming it on photoshop when everyone else came out alright is a lame, weak excuse for his racism.
I have to defend the artist because colour blindness is a real thing and slips like these can occur. Do some googling before you scream “LIES”. I recommend http://colorfilter.wickline.org/
Paste the blog post adress in the filter to view it from the artists perspective. You will see that all the characters have the same matching skin hue in their faces, and Sulu’s cheeto-stained cheeks magically dissapears!
Because teenagerdom is a mess, but some people handle it better than others.
Did you watch the 2013 Academy Awards? Here's our take on the geekiest moments of the show.
© 2013 TheMarySue, LLC |
About Us |
User Agreement |
Dan Abrams, Founder |
Hosting by Datagram