Skip to main content

Woman picks a Marshalls sweater, then the cashier allegedly cuts the loop to get the hanger out and the manager says: ‘She didn’t do anything wrong’

She says the cashier described the loop as “just a thing of string.”

A woman says a Marshalls cashier cut the button loop off a sweater she was buying, and a manager later found no fault with the cashier. She describes the checkout in a Reddit post shared in the r/mildlyinfuriating community. According to The Nerd Stash, the shopper is from Massachusetts. The poster says she had just won an award and headed to the store to buy an outfit in celebration.

She writes that she chose the sweater at Marshalls, which also appeared in a story about selling a lost phone case. She carried it to the register together with a skirt and matching earrings. By her account, the cashier rang up the earrings and took the security tag off the skirt. Next, the cashier reportedly tried to work the hanger out through the neck opening of the sweater.

After about a minute without success, the poster says, the cashier turned the sweater over. She thought the hanger would come out from the bottom, she states, but the cashier picked up scissors and cut the button loop before she could react. The hanger was then pulled free through the widened neck hole, she alleges.

Store staff and the shopper disagreed over the loop

At that point, the poster writes, she stopped the cashier and told her she no longer wanted the sweater. The cashier described the loop as “just a thing of string” and maintained that her actions were fine, she adds. Cancelling the sale, she notes, would require a manager. Shortly afterward, the poster recalls, the cashier returned accompanied by a manager. After she explained the situation, she says, the manager backed the cashier and stated, “She didn’t do anything wrong, it’s just a little loop, no damage.”

She asked for the entire purchase to be cancelled and left the store without the sweater. She ends the post with the sentence “I really wanted that sweater!” All details are based on the poster’s account in her post, which presents only her version of events. The cashier’s and the manager’s sides of the story have not been heard.

The Federal Trade Commission lists writing a complaint letter and contacting a local Better Business Bureau among the steps available to shoppers after a problem with a business. One example involved customers who accused a Walmart employee of breaking a dirt bike inside the box.

Marshalls states that in-store purchases can be returned within 30 days for an exchange or refund. Its in-store return policy adds that merchandise in unsellable condition will not be accepted for a refund, merchandise credit or exchange. The chain’s contact page lists an in-store experience as a topic customers can write about.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Anshu Thakur is a writer who covers culture and trending stories across the internet. Her work focuses on the intersection of internet trends, entertainment, and fan reactions.