Skip to main content

California mother says her son was slapped and called a ‘monkey’ at school, but the 11-year-old who allegedly did it is too young to be charged

Fourteen years old and calmer than most adults I know, and he still had to be the one who kept it together.

A California mother says her 14-year-old son was called a “monkey” and slapped across the face by an 11-year-old during an after-school basketball game at his middle school. Entrepreneur Elani Kay told Atlanta Black Star that school police filed a report, but the 11-year-old cannot be pursued in juvenile court as he is under the state’s minimum age of 12.

Kay, who posted on Threads, said her son confronted the younger boy over the slur. He reportedly put his hand in the boy’s face and said, “Hey, don’t ever talk like that to me again. Don’t call me that name.” The 11-year-old then allegedly slapped him and ran off, and Kay said after-school aides saw the slap.

The other boy’s mother reportedly yelled, cursed, and made threats when contacted, which led administrators to call school police. An officer later said Kay’s son handled himself better than “90% of other grown men” would have. Kay worries her son, who is about six feet tall, may be held to adult expectations because of how Black boys are sometimes perceived as older than they are.

Kay braced for the school to let her down again

Kay said the incident brought back painful memories of racial mistreatment in high school, when she felt officials failed to protect her. However, this time the school’s dean was empathetic and quick to respond. “When your kids are in school, you guys are not here to protect them. So it’s our responsibility to do that,” the dean told Kay.

View post on Threads

The 11-year-old has since apologized to her son, though Kay said she does not know how the school disciplined him. She hopes the police involvement “awakens something in that family,” as she believes the boy might have been arrested had he been 12. Kay said her son was proud of his own restraint after both the slur and the slap.

Kay also questioned whether the school’s talks about racial slurs are working, as her son regularly hears classmates use the N-word. “I do not think that there is anything political about protecting our kids,” Kay said.

One year of age changes everything under California law

California set 12 as the floor for juvenile court jurisdiction when Senate Bill 439 amended Welfare and Institutions Code Section 602. Children under 12 can only be brought before a juvenile court if they are accused of murder or certain forcible sex offenses. An alleged slap falls well outside those exceptions.

The boy’s age does not prevent the school from taking disciplinary action. Under California Education Code Section 48900.3, students in grades four through 12 may be suspended or recommended for expulsion for certain acts of hate violence. However, Kay said she does not know what disciplinary action the school took.

The slur itself carries a documented history. A study published by the American Psychological Association, found that people who associated Black people with apes were more likely to perceive Black children as older and less innocent. Students in one experiment, shown photos alongside crime descriptions, overestimated the ages of Black boys by an average of 4.5 years.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

A girl that has been passionate about anime and gaming ever since she was exposed to it. If she isn't watching anime, she's keeping in touch with the latest news and tech features.