Police say a California man was never reported missing after his head was found in a trash bag, and now his wife and daughter have been arrested
Imagine being told for years that your relative was just keeping to himself, then hearing this.

The wife and daughter of a California man are in custody more than four years after his head was found inside a trash bag in Placer County. Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. was never reported missing, and the sheriff’s office now alleges the two women told relatives he was still alive, according to People.
A woman walking her dog in Foresthill came across human remains in a trash bag in 2022, but they were too decomposed to identify. Investigators found no DNA match in the FBI’s national database and sent a sample to Othram Labs for genetic genealogy testing. The testing led to a cold case breakthrough, as it pointed detectives toward relatives who helped confirm Fitzmaurice’s identity.
Detectives served a search warrant at the family’s Citrus Heights home on Tuesday and arrested 45-year-old Mary Fitzmaurice and her 75-year-old mother, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice. Mary was booked on a murder charge, as investigators allege she killed her father inside the home. Gwenn was booked on an accessory charge and is accused of helping dispose of the remains.
Relatives were reportedly told he was keeping to himself
Investigators claim the mother and daughter kept up a cover story for years. “Through that investigation, we discovered that Gwen and Mary had kept up the facade to family and friends that Paul was still alive,” Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo said. Woo added that the women kept collecting Fitzmaurice’s Social Security benefits and CalPERS pension.
According to Woo, the women leaned on Fitzmaurice’s estrangement from other relatives to explain his absence. They allegedly claimed he struggled with substance abuse, lived like a recluse, and would disappear for days at a time. The story reportedly held that he still returned home every week or so for a couple of days.
Only Fitzmaurice’s head has been recovered, and the rest of his remains have not been located. However, the sheriff’s office has not shared a possible motive, and Woo said the investigation remains ongoing. Investigators also have not said when Fitzmaurice is believed to have died.
Nobody reported him missing, and that likely made the DNA search harder
The FBI’s Combined DNA Index System, known as CODIS, compares unidentified remains against profiles of missing persons and their biological relatives. As Fitzmaurice was never reported missing, there was likely no family reference sample for his DNA to match. Forensic genetic genealogy instead searches for distant cousins and builds family trees until a likely identity emerges.
The alleged benefit payments may also draw scrutiny as the case moves forward. Federal rules say Social Security cannot pay benefits for the month a recipient dies, and any payment covering that month or later must be returned. However, the two women have so far only been booked on the murder and accessory charges.
Mary and Gwenn Fitzmaurice are expected to be arraigned Thursday, according to jail records, while detectives continue working to determine exactly what happened inside the Citrus Heights home.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]