Three people allegedly try to steal vintage fur coats from Brooklyn shop, then employee locks them inside: ‘It was super scary’
The suitcase gave them away.

Three people allegedly tried to steal vintage fur coats from a Brooklyn store by hiding the merchandise inside a rolling suitcase. However, an employee noticed what was happening, recovered the coats, and briefly locked the group inside the shop when they attempted to leave.
The incident happened at Sun Prophet Vintage’s pop-up shop on Bedford Avenue in Williamsburg on November 14. Surveillance footage showed two men and a woman entering the store, with one of the men carrying a large suitcase. While employee Emily Economos helped the woman try on coats, the two men moved toward the back of the shop.
According to the New York Post, the men allegedly attempted to put several fur coats inside the suitcase while their companion distracted Economos. The employee eventually noticed their movements and checked the luggage, finding coats inside. One of the pieces was valued at $6,000, News 12 reported.
She noticed something was happening behind her
Economos initially treated the group like ordinary customers. However, she shared how she started sensing something was wrong while helping the woman try on clothes.”I just got the sense that something was going on behind me,” she recalled.
When she noticed one of the men attempting to place a large coat inside the suitcase, Economos took the merchandise back. She then checked the luggage and discovered another coat inside. Surveillance footage showed her pulling the suitcase away as one of the men reached for it.
According to the store’s owner, Evan Kenefick, Economos briefly locked the three people inside the shop before eventually allowing them to leave. The employee decided it was safer to let the group go after recovering the merchandise.
Economos described the experience as frightening, although she said she acted instinctively during the encounter. “It was super scary, but in the moment, I was just kind of acting on instinct,” she said.
The incident also prompted the store to change some of its security procedures. Kenefick said the business introduced full-time security and new rules restricting customers from entering with hoods and suitcases.
Other retailers have taken different approaches to suspected shoplifting. Some, for example, follow retailers’ no-chase policies, which restrict employees from pursuing or physically stopping suspected shoplifters. At another store, a former employee recalled being instructed to approach suspected shoplifters and offer them another item as part of the company’s loss-prevention strategy.
The owner also shared the surveillance footage online to alert other small businesses about the incident. “We have to stick together as small business owners,” Kenefick said.
The employee called the police, but there’s another detail
Economos said she contacted the police following the incident. However, according to her account, responding officers told her there was little they could do because none of the merchandise had actually left the store.
News 12 contacted the New York Police Department to clarify the officers’ response and determine whether an investigation was underway. The department had not responded by the outlet’s publication on November 17.
Economos has worked with the business for five years. Despite the frightening encounter, she said her response came naturally in the moment, rather than from any elaborate plan to stop the group.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]