Skip to main content

Parents followed suspicious babysitter home, then they discovered a house with 27 children left unattended: ‘There was no food, no water, no toys’

The couple allegedly heard children screaming inside the home

A babysitter who admitted to leaving more than 20 unsupervised children alone in her home has been sentenced to two years in prison. Amanda Mathewson pleaded guilty to child abandonment and neglect of children in her care. Her deceptive babysitting plot was uncovered by parents who became suspicious of the woman and followed her to her home.

Mathewson, who had been a registered childminder in Scotland for 30 years and was registered to care for up to eight children at a time, was found to have 27 children in her home, according to People. A judge later said that 15 of the children had been younger than 12, 10 were under primary school age, and two were under a year old. 

In 2023, Mathewson had been praised for her “warmth, kindness and nurturing approach,” after an unannounced visit from the care inspectorate, reports BBC News. However, a year later, parents discovered that she had been babysitting numerous children at her home and leaving them unattended for extended periods of time.

Suspicious parents followed Amanda Mathewson home

In August 2024, one couple became suspicious after a friend had told them that they had seen Mathewson out on a school run; however, the friend claimed that the couple’s two children, aged one and three, had not been with her when she saw her.

The father, who has not been named, told the BBC that they had followed Mathewson in secret, following her to her home and parking outside during a time when their two boys were supposed to be in her care. The couple claimed they saw their babysitter leave the home to collect other children from school.

After watching her leave, the father said they went to the front door where they could hear a child screaming inside. The couple entered the property through a side gate where they discovered several unsupervised children playing. They were able to get inside the house via the back door, where they found more children; one was allegedly “lying under a table” and crying.

The father also said that they found children sitting on the floor upstairs while a TV loudly played a children’s program. Two more were found “tightly strapped into a buggy in a way it was not meant to be used.”

The father claimed that it was during a warm Summer and that the room was hot. He also said, “There was no food, no water, no toys, no activities for the children to be engaged in.”

When Mathewson returned, the father described her reaction, saying it was “like her soul had left her body.” She was subsequently arrested and charged and pleaded guilty in October.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Jordan is a contributing writer who has bylines on numerous publication. He has a Masters Degree in Creative Writing and loves telling that to anyone who will listen. Aside from that he often spends time getting lost in films, books and games. He particularly enjoys the fantasy genre, ranging from The Legend of Zelda to The Lord of the Rings. Jordan specializes in covering News, True Crime, Social Media, Politics, and Celebrities.