New York Server Gets a Table of Fussy Customers, Then He Decided to Lie and Ended Up With a 35% Tip: ‘I Could Probably Lose My Job’
That’s a morally gray tactic.
Dealing with difficult table complaints is part of the job in food service. But figuring out how to flip an unhappy group into a big tip takes serious improvisational skills. And New York server Dean Redmond (@deanredmonds) allegedly mastered that skill using a white lie.
In a TikTok storytime sitting at nearly 28,000 views, Redmond broke down how a deliberate lie turned a table of chronic complainers into remorseful, big-spending diners. It saved him from hearing any more complaints, while also allegedly filling his pocket. So, a win-win.
While most servers would think of a fussy table as a headache, Redmond treated it as an opportunity to test a wild, unhinged customer service tactic. And now he’s advising every customer service worker to use it.
A picky table complained about calamari and dry chicken piccata
The service nightmare began when a table allegedly asked Redmond to choose their appetizer for them. When Redmond hesitated, they insisted that they weren’t picky. But when he brought out spicy fried calamari, the group allegedly turned it down. They claimed that they didn’t like shrimp while Redmond gently informed them that calamari is actually squid. However, the table then demanded “no fishes.”
So, Redmond replaced the dish with free bread baskets and the entrees finally arrived. But according to him, the complaints didn’t stop. One male diner allegedly scoffed at his chicken piccata, complaining that the dish was dry. The customer then reportedly demanded to know what was going on in the kitchen.
“We’re just not having a pleasant meal. The appetizer wasn’t good, and now this? What’s going on in the kitchen?”
The server decided to lie and create a fake sob story to dodge the complaints
Refusing to let the negativity ruin his shift, Redmond decided to invent an outrageously tragic backstory on the spot. Staring the man dead in the eye, he lowered his voice and delivered an Oscar-worthy performance.
“Sir, I am so sorry, and I could probably lose my job for telling you this, but our chef’s mom passed away yesterday, and she’s the creator of that chicken piccata.”
The server’s dramatic lie produced an instant, dramatic reaction from the entire table. Forks hit the plates, the diners gasped in collective horror, and a woman at the table even swatted the complaining diner on the shoulder for speaking out.
By the time Redmond returned with soda refills, the complaining customer was allegedly staring blankly into space in complete emotional shock. Overcome with guilt, the table reportedly apologized profusely for their earlier complaints and promised to leave a stellar online review.
To Redmond’s surprise, they also allegedly rewarded him with a massive 35% tip on their final bill. This prompted the server and creator to jokingly tell his fellow servers to “lie to your customers.”
Why an absurd white lie can flip toxic table dynamics
Navigating customer service under pressure often requires creative de-escalation tactics. But resorting to a guilt-inducing lie is a high-risk move that only works under specific circumstances.
When customers enter a restaurant looking for things to criticize, confronting them directly often leads to escalating arguments or bad reviews. By inventing a somber personal crisis behind the kitchen doors, Redmond disarmed their entitlement. This forced the table to re-evaluate their harsh behavior even if the story was entirely fabricated.
For him, the lying tactic allegedly worked. However, it still isn’t the best way to handle conflicts with customers. So, the story remains good to laugh about, but shouldn’t be taken as an inspiration.
Redmond joked about his risky strategy after securing the payout
Reflecting on the shift from his car, Redmond laughed off his unorthodox customer management style, celebrating his 35% payout. He hinted that picking a fight with your server is never a good idea.
For the customers, if your chicken piccata tastes a little off, just ask for a fresh plate. Because if your server is anything like Redmond, you might otherwise end up disassociating over a fake tragedy and paying a 35% penalty for it.
Have you ever caught a server telling a hilarious white lie to fix a table dispute?
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
