Parents say their toddlers were ‘not acting normal’ at daycare pickup. Then they discover what teachers allegedly gave them during nap time
The motive behind the alleged acts have yet to be revealed.

Three former teachers of a daycare in Forsyth, Georgia, allegedly administered medication to toddlers to make them sleep without a prescription or parental authorization. Cathy Carlisle Stevick, Kendasja Mequia Hughley, and Shelby Ashlynn Webb have been indicted on 23 counts of reckless conduct and first-degree cruelty to children on Monday, Nov. 9, stemming from incidents at the Forsyth Methodist Church’s Caring for Kids in March 2025.
The investigation reportedly began when a teacher filed a report that toddlers were allegedly being given Benadryl, an antihistamine that causes drowsiness, to induce sleep during nap time at the daycare. Investigators said at least three children, some as young as two years old, were administered the medication on two separate occasions, according to Law&Crime.
“This teacher had apparently been doing this for a longer period of time with some children,” Reg Griffin from the Georgia Department of Early Care and Learning told WGXA. “The only idea the parents had was when they picked up their children at the end of the day, they were extremely sluggish and not acting normal.”
Daycare teachers allegedly hit the toddlers too
The alleged drugging of the toddlers was not the only concern investigators had. According to Griffin, there were instances when the teachers “basically wrestled” the young children down to a mat when they were trying to go back inside the classroom.
Hughley was the first of the trio to be arrested on March 10, 2025, by the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office. The Monroe County Superior Court charged her with six felony counts of cruelty to children, five counts of reckless conduct, and seven counts of simple battery stemming from allegations that she physically mistreated multiple toddlers by kicking, hitting, grabbing, and pulling them by their hair, per WGMT.
Webb and Stevick were both arrested eight days later. Webb was charged with one count of first-degree cruelty to children and one count of simple battery. Court documents alleged Webb struck a child and threw one out of a chair.
Stevick, who served as a director at Forsyth Methodist Church’s Caring for Kids, faces three counts of failure to report child abuse. Under Georgia law, professionals, including school officials, are required to report suspected child neglect, abandonment, abuse, or exploitation to the appropriate authorities.
The daycare was ultimately closed after investigators obtained surveillance footage of the alleged offenses being committed and determined that the children were in imminent danger. Reportedly, the Houston County District Attorney’s Office will handle the case moving forward, and the victims’ parents are suing the facility and staff members separately.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]