Judge unseals Epstein’s ‘final note’. But the real question is why did the DOJ keep it hidden for years?
Release the files.
A U.S. judge just unsealed a document that’s being called Jeffrey Epstein’s “suicide note,” but the bigger story might be why the Department of Justice kept it hidden for years. According to Al Jazeera, the note, handwritten on a yellow legal pad, was released by US District Judge Kenneth Karas on May 6, 2026, as part of the criminal case against Nicholas Tartaglione, Epstein’s former cellmate.
The judge didn’t vouch for its authenticity, just ruled it was a judicial document the public had a right to see. The note itself is short and reads like a mix of defiance and dark humor. “They investigated me for month – Found NOTHING!!! So 15 year old charges resulted,” it says. Then it takes a turn: “It is a treat to be able to choose ones time to say goodbye. Watcha want me to do – Burst out cryin!! NO FUN – NOT WORTH IT!!”
The tone is jarring, especially coming from someone who was facing life in prison for sex trafficking charges. Epstein was found dead in his Manhattan jail cell on August 10, 2019, in what authorities ruled a suicide. He’d been awaiting trial at the time, and his death sparked endless conspiracy theories given his high-profile connections.
The cellmate has his own version of the story
Tartaglione, a former police officer serving four consecutive life sentences for drug-related murders, said he found the note tucked inside a book in their shared cell in July 2019. He’d mentioned the note before in a podcast interview, but its existence gained wider attention after The New York Times reported last year that federal investigators never saw it.
What’s even more striking is that the note was missing from the millions of Epstein-related documents the DOJ has released in recent years. That’s raised eyebrows, especially since Congress passed a bipartisan bill last year requiring the Department of Justice to release all files related to its Epstein investigation. The DOJ has since dumped millions of pages, but lawmakers are still asking how complete the release really is.
The timing of the note’s release is also interesting
Epstein died just weeks after Tartaglione said he found it. If it’s real, it’s one of the last things Epstein wrote before his death. But if it’s not, it’s a bizarre piece of theater, either planted by someone or fabricated entirely. Tartaglione’s lawyer, Bruce Barket, has been adamant that his client didn’t forge the note.
“There’s no debate” over it, Barket told TMZ even as skeptics online and on TV have questioned its legitimacy. One Reddit user pointed out that the handwriting doesn’t match Epstein’s confirmed letters, while others have noted that a 2019 letter Epstein allegedly sent to fellow convicted sex offender Larry Nassar was later proven fake.
Fox News correspondent Kevin Corke said on Laura Ingraham’s show that an Epstein family member doesn’t believe the note is genuine. The DOJ, for its part, hasn’t confirmed its authenticity either, and the note wasn’t even signed. That’s left a lot of room for speculation, especially since Epstein’s death has never been fully put to rest in the public’s mind.
Tartaglione’s story about finding the note is already under scrutiny
He said that he discovered it in a graphic novel after Epstein’s first suicide attempt. He said he turned it over to his lawyers, thinking it might help his case if Epstein kept accusing him of assault. Epstein had initially claimed Tartaglione attacked him, but later said he had no issues with his cellmate. Tartaglione has always denied any wrongdoing, and his lawyer has pushed back hard against suggestions that he played any role in Epstein’s death.
The bigger question, though, is why the note was kept under wraps for so long. If it’s real, it’s a significant piece of evidence that should have been part of the public record years ago. If it’s fake, it’s a bizarre distraction that’s only muddied the waters further. Either way, the DOJ’s decision to withhold it, even as it released millions of other documents, has only fueled suspicions.
Congress is already digging deeper, subpoenaing current and former officials, including Bill and Hillary Clinton, to testify about their ties to Epstein. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick was grilled by the House Oversight Committee this week after documents showed he’d met with Epstein as recently as 2012, despite claiming he’d cut ties in 2005.
None of this means anyone connected to Epstein is guilty of a crime. To date, no one in the US has been criminally charged in connection with his alleged activities, though officials in other countries, like UK’s Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, have faced legal consequences. But the lack of clarity around Epstein’s death, combined with the DOJ’s uneven document dumps, has made it hard for the public to move on. The note is just the latest piece of a puzzle that still feels far from complete.
(Featured image: Stephen Ogilvy)
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
