Chicago card shop owner says a man sold him cards, then pocketed 4 Pokémon cards worth $6,500 from a box by the register
Paying a guy for his cards and then watching him pocket mine on camera would keep me up for weeks.

A man who sold cards to a Chicago card shop allegedly pocketed four of the store’s Pokémon cards worth about $6,500, according to CBS. Owner Nick Bruni blames himself, as the cards were in a box of new inventory by the register. “Just had this box of inventory sitting right here. Obviously, huge error on my part,” Bruni said.
Bruni, who opened Oldskool TCG in the Avondale neighborhood a few months ago, said the same man had also sold him cards during the visit. That means Bruni paid him money on top of losing the four cards. “So, I both gave him money for cards he sold me, and he took,” Bruni said.
Bruni has since filed a police report over the missing cards, though police are classifying the incident as simple retail theft. He said having his trust broken by a customer is what really gets to him, and that thefts at card shops are “becoming more and more of a common occurrence.”
The camera caught what Bruni missed at the register
Bruni told the outlet he likes to keep everything behind glass, as the cards he sells carry serious value. However, a new shipment had just arrived, and the box sat by the register while he helped a customer. One of the four Pokémon cards taken from it is worth more than $4,000 on its own, according to Bruni.
Surveillance footage appears to show Bruni helping another customer while the man digs through the nearby box. The video then appears to show him slipping cards into his pocket. Bruni has shared the clips with police and the public to help identify him.
Bruni, whom CBS described as a Pokémon connoisseur, said he worked hard to build the business and makes a point of treating every visitor with respect. He also says he trusts the people who walk through his door.
Chicago card shops keep finding out how tempting their stock is
Bruni’s shop is not the first in Chicago to lose Pokémon cards this year. In April, burglars smashed through the front window of Elite Sports Cards and Comics in the Dunning neighborhood and took more than $100,000 in Pokémon cards and sports collectibles, per NBC.
Jared Mast, whose wealth management firm deals in collectibles, told ABC that card values have climbed sharply over the past year, with some fans lining up outside stores overnight for new stock. He said mass-printed Pokémon cards are easy targets, as one copy looks identical to the next, and that stolen cards often resurface on online marketplaces or get resubmitted for grading. However, grading companies do keep their own records.
After thieves stole thousands of PSA-certified cards from a FedEx truck in Southern California last month, PSA published a stolen-card list of 6,451 items, per Sports Illustrated. Pokémon cards made up 2,978 of them, about 46% of the list, though the outlet noted that the list leaves out each card’s grade.
No arrest has been reported, and any charge could hinge on the cards’ value, as Illinois treats retail theft over $300 as a Class 3 felony punishable by two to five years in prison and up to $25,000 in fines, per FindLaw.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]