Brandon Flynn’s James Dean biopic finds its Bill Bast, and the queer Hollywood romance everyone whispered about is finally getting a screen
The biopic that wants to know who James Dean was when the cameras stopped rolling

Hollywood spent seven decades polishing James Dean into the ultimate straight rebel heartthrob, and now a small indie is gleefully picking at the paint. Brandon Flynn is set to play the Rebel Without a Cause icon in One Hand Tied, and the film has just found the man who will play Dean’s alleged first love. Half Man star Mitchell Robertson has been cast as Bill Bast, Dean’s UCLA roommate, close friend, and alleged lover.
The news, first reported by The Hollywood Reporter, adds a second name to a project that has been quietly simmering since Flynn’s casting was announced in June 2025. Back then, the film was known as Willie and Jimmy Dean. It has since been retitled, and the new name is a delicious piece of Old Hollywood trivia. It nods to one of the few times Dean addressed the rumors about his sexuality, when he reportedly said he wasn’t gay but wasn’t going to live “with one hand tied behind my back.”
If you’re wondering why it took this long for someone to make this movie, you’re not alone. Dean made only three films before dying in a car crash at 24, yet his shadow still looms over how we picture masculinity on screen. The rumors about his love life have never gone away, and a feature film seriously exploring them has been missing from the conversation for more than 70 years.
Who is Bill Bast?
Bast was a young writer who met Dean in the UCLA theater program when Bast was 19. By his own account, the two became friends, then roommates, then lovers. He later wrote about it in his 2006 memoir Surviving James Dean, which the film draws on. Bast claimed that the pair kept the relationship under wraps because Dean’s rising career couldn’t survive the scandal, especially as gossip swirled around him and big names like Rock Hudson and Marlon Brando.
The film’s script also stems from writer-director Guy Guido’s 2011 interview with Bast, conducted just four years before Bast’s death. The story starts with the pair’s first meeting and runs through Dean’s death on Sept. 30, 1955. Rather than a greatest-hits tour of the star’s career, the film promises to center on how the two men navigated a relationship they couldn’t be open about, and on Bast coming to terms with his own sexuality.
Guido has been upfront that this isn’t meant to be a standard cradle-to-grave biopic. He has said the project interests him as a look at the human being behind decades of mythology, not as a total reinvention of Dean. He also acknowledged that some fans cling tightly to the brooding, cigarette-dangling image and bristle at any suggestion that the truth was more complicated.
Who is in the cast so far?
Only two roles have been announced, and both are intriguing. Flynn, best known for 13 Reasons Why, True Detective, and Manhunt, is leading the film, and he’s become something of a go-to for queer icons after playing Marlon Brando in the Off-Broadway production Kowalski. Robertson, who recently appeared in Netflix’s Half Man, rounds out the central pair.
Flynn, who is openly gay, has been vocal about why this story matters. In an earlier interview with Variety, he suggested Dean’s legacy as the ultimate masculine ideal is part of why the gay narrative has been avoided, arguing that audiences and studios are still uncomfortable with it. He has also said that telling these stories matters because Dean wasn’t the only one who lived this way.
Guido directs from his own script. His previous credits include Madonna and the Breakfast Club, a Hulu feature.
When can we expect to see it?
Not anytime soon. As of this writing, One Hand Tied hasn’t started filming, and no release date or distributor has been announced. Beyond Flynn, Robertson, and Guido, nobody else has been confirmed, so the rest of the supporting cast, which could include the stars who orbited Dean in the 1950s, remains a mystery.
Still, the casting of Bast is the kind of milestone that moves a long-rumored project from “wouldn’t it be wild if” to “oh, this is actually happening.” Dean has been a canvas for other people’s fantasies for generations. This film wants to ask who he was when the cameras weren’t on, and we’ll be watching to see how it answers.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]