‘I wan’t my…$500 back’: Woman brings Claire’s ‘real diamond collection’ earrings to jewelry shop. Then she gets them tested

A TikToker demanded a refund from Claire’s after finding out the diamond earrings she bought were fake. The former manager claimed to get them tested by a jeweler.

The video sparked debate over whether Claire’s actually sells “real diamonds” and if lab-grown diamonds are in fact real diamonds.

What did she buy at Claire’s?

Content creator Taye Elizabeth (@tayeelizabeth) shared a viral video with over 298,800 viewers. She claimed to spend $500 on earrings from the Claire’s piercing collection. Taye stated that they were advertised as gold diamond earrings.

In the clip, Taye said she recently took the earrings to be tested in hopes of selling them to pay bills. Unfortunately, the jeweler told her the stones and the gold were fake. 

“I want my $500 back,” she stated in the video.

Taye explained the discovery was especially upsetting because she previously worked as a manager for Claire’s. During that time, she sold those earrings for about two years.

She questioned whether she assisted in misleading customers about their purchases.

“I worked there for 2 years selling people FAKE A** DIAMONDS AND GOLD,” she angrily stated.

Why did viewers question the creator’s expectations?

Many viewers were surprised that anyone would expect real diamonds from Claire’s. 

“Buying ‘real diamonds’ from CLAIIRES is the most obvious red flag ever,” said one user.

“Claire’s? You trusted Claire’s? Are you ok,” questioned another.

For those users, Taye’s expectations were unrealistic.

However, the creator pushed back against the backlash. For her, it was the retailer’s responsibility to sell products as advertised. She was further dismayed that it jeopardized her own integrity when she worked there as a manager.

Other viewers sided with Taye. They were concerned that commenters were blaming her.

“Not yall blaming her when the store that sold them to her framed them as something else,” one user stated.

Does Claire’s sell real diamonds?

Many viewers questioned whether Claire’s sells real diamonds. 

“Lmfao, I have NEVER seen Claire’s advertise real diamonds,” stated one user.

The store is primarily known for selling fashion and costume jewelry. However, the retailer also sells piercing jewelry with precious metals and stones. This collection features lab-grown diamonds.

A Claire’s advertisement read: “Sparkle Smarter. We’ll spare you the science – our lab-grown diamonds are the real deal.”

Are lab-grown diamonds real?

Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds. They are not imitation stones like cubic zirconias. The artificially made diamonds have the same chemical composition and crystal structure as naturally occurring diamonds.

Do lab diamonds pass a diamond tester?

Then the comments quickly shifted to a debate over diamond testing.

Many viewers argued that due to both types of diamonds having the same chemical and physical properties, they should have the same result.

Additionally, experts agree. 

They claim that both lab-grown and natural-mined diamonds have the same chemical structure. The stones are pure carbon in a crystalline form. 

Diamond testers measure thermal or electrical conductivity. Since both diamond types conduct heat in the same way, testers will read them as genuine.

@tayeelizabeth what in the actual…. I went to sell my diamonds for bill money and they aren't even real… @Claire's thought your diamonds we're legit??? I worked here for 2 years selling people FAKE ASS DIAMONDS AND GOLD. #fake #claires #runmemymoney #ihavereceipts ♬ original sound – TAYLR

Can older testers cause a false reading?

A lab-grown diamond will usually pass testing without an issue. However, older testers may confuse some HPHT-grown diamonds due to tiny amounts of boron in the structure.

This can possibly explain why the diamonds failed the test. There is no evidence confirming what the earrings are made of nor what testing method was used. 

Nonetheless, Taye’s video sparked a broader conversation about lab-grown diamonds and retailers’ responsibility to their customers.

The Mary Sue contacted Claire’s via email and Taye Elizabeth via TikTok direct message.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]