Massachusetts Town Warns Homeowners That Flying American Flags Could Violate Endangered Species Laws, Sparking a Constitutional Standoff
Massachusetts homeowners on Plum Island just got a notice that could put a damper on their Fourth of July plans. According to Fox News, the Town of Newbury sent letters warning residents that flying American flags on their own property might violate state and federal endangered species laws. The move has sparked a constitutional showdown. Homeowners calling it an overreach and legal experts questioning whether the town has any authority to enforce such rules.
The letter, which landed in mailboxes last week, specifically listed “mylar streamers, flags, and reflective materials” as potential violations of laws protecting endangered shorebirds. According to the notice, these items could be seen as “harassment or disruption of normal feeding, nesting, or migratory behavior,” which is prohibited under the Endangered Species Acts.
The town didn’t mince words about the consequences, either. Non-compliance could lead to “state or federal enforcement actions” and “significant regulatory and financial penalties.” That’s a heavy warning for something as simple as hanging a flag.
Residents weren’t having it
Marc Sarkady, who’s lived on Plum Island for over 30 years, said the letter left him stunned. He asked, “Are you serious? You’re telling me I can’t fly American flags on my property to celebrate America 250?”
Sarkady and other locals had already kicked off a grassroots effort to distribute American flags and revolutionary-style signs ahead of the nation’s 250th anniversary. They handed out around 50 flags and 100 signs with the message “Plum Island Honors America,” aiming to bring the community together. Now, they’re wondering if their patriotic displays could land them in legal trouble.
Town officials are pushing back against the idea that they’re trying to ban flags. Newbury Town Administrator Tracy Blais said the town is “not in any way attempting to interfere with the property owner’s rights to use their property or to restrict their use of their property for ordinary and patriotic purposes.” Instead, she claimed the town was just passing along a request from MassWildlife to remind residents about protecting endangered species.
“The letter merely recited provisions of the law, and the Town is not asserting any threat or legal liability – merely reminding property owners that they live in a very special place which comes along with certain responsibilities,” Blais said. But the Pacific Legal Foundation, which is representing Sarkady and two of his neighbors, isn’t buying it.
The Pacific Legal Foundation has sought clarity
The group sent a letter to the town’s conservation agent, Mason Ferrick, demanding clarification on whether the town is actually claiming that homeowners can’t display flags on their private property. They also want to know the legal basis for applying endangered species laws to beachfront decorations. According to the PLF, no court has ever found a homeowner liable for displaying decorations under these laws.
Mark Miller, the group’s director of Environment and Natural Resources Litigation, didn’t hold back in his criticism. “Flying the red, white and blue on the Fourth of July is as American as apple pie,” he said. “For Massachusetts local officials to claim otherwise violates both the First and Fifth Amendments to the United States Constitution.”
This isn’t the first time Plum Island residents have clashed with officials over beachfront decorations. Sarkady said a similar letter was sent to one of his neighbors last year after she put up ornamental banners. He claimed a MassWildlife official called her directly, threatening fines and even jail time if she didn’t take them down.
The neighbor, feeling intimidated, complied. MassWildlife has denied those claims, insisting it has never prohibited residents from displaying American flags or threatened penalties. Still, the pattern of warnings has left residents feeling like they’re walking on eggshells.
The timing of the letter couldn’t be worse
Plum Island is already dealing with another environmental crisis that’s hitting closer to home. According to CBS News, beaches in the area have been closed indefinitely after millions of gallons of raw sewage were dumped into the Merrimack River in nearby Haverhill.
The initial spill was bad enough, with 60,000 gallons accidentally released. Then crews discovered two breaks in a major sewer line, leading to an estimated 8 to 10 million gallons of raw sewage pumping into the river every day. Newburyport and Ipswich have both closed their beaches as a precaution, with signs warning swimmers to stay out of the water.
Health officials are warning that contact with the contaminated water can cause nausea, vomiting, respiratory issues, and eye irritation. Beachgoer Doug Riley said the smell is noticeable on Plum Island.
“Yeah, we could smell it,” he said. “We live fairly close to the water treatment facility in Newburyport. Every once in a while you can get a smell from that. It was kind of the same smell.” The city is working on a temporary fix, but until then, the beaches remain off-limits.
The sewage spill and the flag controversy might seem unrelated
However, they’re both shining a light on how environmental regulations can clash with everyday life. On one hand, you have laws designed to protect endangered species and public health. On the other, you have homeowners who feel like those laws are being weaponized to restrict their freedoms.
For now, residents are left wondering what they can and can’t do on their own property. If flying an American flag could be seen as “harassment” to a bird, what’s next? Decorating for Halloween? Hanging Christmas lights? The Pacific Legal Foundation is demanding answers, and it’s clear this fight is far from over. In the meantime, Plum Island homeowners are gearing up for a Fourth of July that’s anything but ordinary. Between the closed beaches and the legal threats, it’s shaping up to be a holiday they won’t forget.
(Featured image: Adavyd)
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
