Skip to main content

Woman finds out boyfriend is cheating, so she takes him to Dairy Queen for a ‘cheater sundae.’ She didn’t expect the worker to help so willingly

ice cream sunday (l) couple went for ice cream date (c) DQ entrance (r)

Most who’ve been in relationships know it’s all butterflies and smiles—that is, until you discover your partner is cheating. Regardless of how old you are or how long the relationship lasted, it shatters your heart.

Recommended Videos

Although infidelity has been around since the dawn of time, it seems to be more prevalent than ever. The Survey of American Life found that 46% of women and 34% of men have been the victim of an unfaithful partner. Social media tends to enable these behaviors, making it easier to discreetly connect with strangers, old friends, and past flames.

And the paper trail unearthed in the cheater’s phone can be damning. After allegedly catching her boyfriend cheating red-handed, one woman channels the rage into a public humiliation spectacle at Dairy Queen.

A Cheating Boyfriend Shamed At Dairy Queen

While TikTok creator Paisley Garcia (@sk8pyre) sits in a booth in a Dairy Queen, she is sandwiched between her friend Kaylee and her fiancé Harper. Sitting opposite them is Johnny, Kaylee’s soon-to-be ex-boyfriend.

“Did someone order a Cheater Sundae?” a Dairy Queen employee named Sierra announced, placing a small vanilla sundae, drenched in caramel, and a single 1 blue candle in the center.

“Why is there one?” Garcia questions rhetorically, referring to the candlestick, to which Sierra replies, “Hmm, I guess you gotta figure that out. Enjoy.”

When a heartbeat passes, it ‘clicks.’

“Oh! It’s because it’s gonna be one walk home,” she states, cracking up laughing.

Then, it dawns on Johnny: he was busted.

“Wait, what did you find on my phone?” he inquires, proceeding to reiterate the same question more frantically.

“That was clever. Which one of you set this up?” Harper adds, which Garcia credits to Kaylee. Before the clip ends, it captures Johnny’s reaction: a side-eye and grimacing mouth, cringing.

Of course, Garcia pays her respect to Sierra for bringing the idea to life. “Shoutout to the DQ employee who delivered a Cheater Sundae to my friend’s boyfriend after he cheated on her.”

Needless to say, she dubs in the caption as a “Double date gone wrong.”

Viewers Virtually Applaud

Garcia’s clip garnered over 490,000 views, with many relishing in Johnny’s embarrassment at Dairy Queen.

“Bro not 3 of u on one side,” one viewer commented.

“THIS IS FRYING ME LMAOOOO,” a second stated.

“The ‘enjoyyyyy’ took me outtt,” a third said.

Meanwhile, others insisted Garcia spill the entire tea and details.

“What DID you find on his phone?” one commenter remarked.

“I need the story time,” a second begged.

How To Catch A Cheating Boyfriend

Since viewers demanded, Garcia obliged. In a follow-up video, the trio sat in a car, taking turns about what led to the Dairy Queen debacle. First up was Kaylee.

“So, me and Johnny were dating for a month and a half. We had some issues,” she said. “I found out he was cheating on me the day I got my wisdom teeth removed. I made him bring me ice cream, and I stayed with him.”

Subsequently, the trio hatched up a plan to expose him by playing an innocuous game of truth or dare. “I told Johnny, ‘I dare you to let [Kaylee] go through your phone,’” Harper recalled saying.

When Kaylee dug through Johnny’s phone, she uncovered a landfill of dirty secrets.

“We found him with hickeys all over his chest, him stalking his ex, texting these two girls behind my back, which he was supposed to have blocked, “ Kaylee revealed.

But the cherry on top was Not Safe For Work material. “What’s in his recently deleted violates TikTok guidelines but let’s just say it was inappropriate,” Garcia added.

Enter The Dairy Queen Idea

After witnessing the public reprimand, Sierra called the girls over, where they all concocted the scheme together. Once Sierra approached their table, Garcia recorded the entire scene that went viral.

“She comes over, ‘Did someone order a Cheater Sundae?’” Kaylee recounted her Dairy Queen boss saying.

However, the ‘one walk home’ didn’t pan out because someone saved him from further shame. “He called his mommy to pick him up,” Garcia said. “And he tried to get the worker in trouble.”

“I told everyone what was on his phone that I can’t say on here,” Kaylee said.

“And that’s the story,” the content creator concluded.

@sk8pyre Double date gone wrong #fyp #viral #funny #cheatersgettingcaught #cheater ♬ Dropando Nesse Grave – Cayin22

The Mary Sue reached out to Garcia via TikTok comment and direct message.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Melody Heald is a culture writer. Her work can be found in Glitter Magazine, BUST Magazine, The Daily Dot, and more. You can email her at: [email protected]