Skip to main content

Woman finishes 3 rounds of interviews for an $85,000 paralegal job. Then she finds out why she was allegedly rejected despite being the most qualified

Is it the personality or the money?

User TheDyosel on the paralegal subreddit was rejected for a job after three rounds of interviews. The reason she was given was that it was her personality, but she claimed that she never met the person who decided to reject her, leaving her to believe that it was her $85,000 base salary request that cost her the job.

TheDyosel posted the story for discussion. She established early in the process that she wanted $85,000 as her base salary and wouldn’t go lower than that. Her recruiter told her she was the lead for the position.

The firm’s administrator apparently called TheDyosel the most qualified candidate they had. The role went unfilled, so no other candidate was chosen over her.

She thinks the $85k number cost her the job

She couldn’t prove it, but TheDyosel believed that her refusal to take lower pay was the real reason she got rejected. Early in the post, she said, “My recruiter told me I was in the lead, the firm loved me, and my $85k base was confirmed. Then the firm’s administrator asked my recruiter if I’d come off $85k. I said no, right away — that number was established from my first all the way to the third interview.”

Image by (Reddit/TheDyosel)

TheDyosel then explained that the decision to reject her came from the firm’s owner/partner, whom she never met during her interview process. This led to her saying, “So I was the most qualified, technically the only qualified candidate, and I got passed over for ‘personality’ by someone who never met me — because I wouldn’t come off $85k.”

Commenters think the owner wanted a bargain

Multiple commenters believed that the firm might’ve seen TheDyosel’s base salary request as open to negotiation. One said, “The most likely explanation is that they thought $85k was the start of a negotiation, and the owner got b*****rt that you didn’t want to negotiate. The owner is probably one of these people who needs to feel like they got a deal. ‘My paralegal asked for $85k, but I talked her down to $65k.”

Some commenters asked if TheDyosel was the most qualified candidate or if the administrator she spoke with lied to her. A few commenters in the discussion said that TheDyosel managed to avoid a workplace that wouldn’t value her work and she “dodged a bullet.”

Mismatched salary expectations often lead to job rejections. Abel Personnel lists hidden reasons behind rejections, and one is “when the money doesn’t match: dealing with salary expectations.”

The website lists three main reasons a salary mismatch can happen. Those reasons include asking for more pay than the company can afford, not knowing the average salary for that position, and the company not recognizing the value of your skills.

Being too set on one salary can cost people the position they applied for, and TheDyosel believed that was the case in her recent experience, even if the official reason for her rejection was her personality.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

Melissa has been writing professionally since 2022. While most of her experience has been in gaming and entertainment, she loves finding unusual news stories that cover unexpected events.