U.S. Women’s Soccer Team Players Make Federal Complaint of Wage Discrimination
The complaint was submitted by goalkeeper Hope Solo as well as Carli Lloyd, Becky Sauerbrunn, Alex Morgan, and Megan Rapinoe. In a statement released by team lawyer Jeffrey Kessler, Solo explained “The numbers speak for themselves. We are the best in the world, have three World Cup championships, four Olympic championships.” She went on to say that male players “get paid more to just show up than we get paid to win major championships.”
Kessler, who says this is “the strongest case of discrimination against women athletes in violation of law that I have ever seen,” also offered some background on the ongoing legal dispute between U.S. Soccer and the women’s team:
In early January, the Women’s National Team Players Association submitted a reasonable proposal for a new CBA [Collective Bargaining Agreement] that had equal pay for equal work as its guiding principle. U.S. Soccer responded by suing the players in an effort to keep in place the discriminatory and unfair treatment they have endured for years.
The U.S. men’s team hasn’t placed at a major event since 2002, when they made it to the quarterfinals at the World Cup, but U.S. Soccer argues that the pay discrepancy between the decorated women’s team and the comparatively mediocre men’s team is due in part to the latter’s high attendance numbers. The New York Times explains,
U.S. Soccer officials pushed back forcefully on the players’ claims in a conference call Thursday night, citing figures that the federation said showed the men’s national team produced revenue and attendance about double that of the women’s team, and television ratings that were “a multiple” of what the women attract, according to Sunil Gulati, the U.S. Soccer president. A federation spokesman, Neil Buethe, called some of the revenue figures in the players’ complaint “inaccurate, misleading or both.”
Players on the women’s team are salaried (the Times estimates that the team’s stars make around $72,000 a year), while players on the men’s team are only paid if they are called to the national team. Still, Solo and the other women argue that the way the league’s bonus structure works is unfair. Via ESPN:
The women would earn $99,000 each if they won 20 friendlies, the minimum number they are required to play in a year. But the men would likely earn $263,320 each for the same feat, and would get $100,000 even if they lost all 20 games. Additionally, the women get paid nothing for playing more than 20 games, while the men get between $5,000 and $17,625 for each game played beyond 20.
A discrepancy is also evident in the teams’ World Cup earnings, although World Cup prize money itself is determined by FIFA, not U.S. Soccer. When the women’s team won the World Cup in 2015, they earned a team total of $2 million. By contrast, when the men’s team was eliminated in the round of 16 of the 2014 World Cup, they earned a team total of $9 million.
Russell Sauer, outside counsel for the U.S. Soccer federation during labor talks, says of the complaint “The truth is, the players are claiming discrimination based on a more conservative structure, based on guaranteed compensation rather than pay to play, which they themselves requested, negotiated and approved of not once, but twice.”
Sauer also points out that the women’s contract includes benefits, such as severance and injury pay, not available to the male players. However, since the complaint was filed on Wednesday, the women’s team has received vocal support from their male peers, including goalie Tim Howard, who said his team supports the women in their efforts:
We support the fact that the women should fight for their rights and fight for what they think is just compensation. We, on the men’s side, have been fighting that battle for a long, long time. We certainly know what it feels like. We felt underpaid for a long time. We had to negotiate our way to a settlement.
ESPN reports that U.S. Soccer President Suni Gulati said during the Thursday night conference call, “We think very highly of the women’s national team and we want to compensate them fairly, and we’ll sit down and work through that with them when all of this settles down.”
—The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—