Turkish man convicted of pushing his wife off a cliff to collect insurance money is set free after 6 years as Supreme Court reviews his life sentence
His case isn't yet closed.

Hakan Aysal has recently been freed from the high-security prison where he was being held while the Criminal General Assembly of Turkey’s Supreme Court reviews an appeal of his life sentence, according to the New York Post. He was six years into his sentence at the time of release.
Aysal was sentenced for pushing his pregnant wife off a 1,000-foot cliff, resulting in the death of her and the unborn baby, for the insurance payout. However, his lawyers claim that there wasn’t enough convincing evidence to brand him as her killer.
Throughout the ordeal, Aysal has stuck with his claim of innocence. According to him, he turned away from his wife for a moment, and when he turned around, she was gone.
A witness recorded the incident in 2018
The New York Post reported on the incident in 2021 when a tourist produced a video of Aysal and his wife on the cliff on the day of her death. It allegedly shows the couple walking together before her death, which is claimed to have been caused by Aysal pushing her.
When the case was tried, prosecutors argued that it wasn’t an accident and was instead premeditated murder due to Aysal taking out a life insurance policy for his wife, making himself the beneficiary, and then trying to collect the payout after her death. Aysal was apparently unable to claim the payout following his wife’s death due to the investigation into it.
Women’s rights groups are concerned about the precedent that could be set by Aysal being freed while the appeal is under review. One lawyer said on the matter, “The decision is extremely worrying, not only for this case but also in terms of the evaluation of evidence in femicide cases and the debates surrounding impunity.”
Aysal isn’t exactly free for good
It seems that, under Turkish law, the Supreme Court issuing an appellate reversal sends the case back to trial. While it goes through being retried, Aysal will be free from detention and could end up having his conviction overturned.
Aysal was serving an aggravated life sentence and could return to having the same sentence depending on the outcome of his appeal that led to his current freedom. An aggravated life sentence is slightly different from a normal life sentence, and it’s usually the result of a more severe crime.
An aggravated life sentence is the most severe sanction in Turkish Criminal Law, according to Legal Crab, and usually requires that the convict be in prison for at least 30 years before being eligible for a conditional release. This again depends on the nature of the crime.
For Aysal, the future isn’t clear. He has his freedom because of his appeal, but information regarding the next steps in his case doesn’t appear to be available yet.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]