— Black Girl Nerds (@BlackGirlNerds) January 8, 2018
Leading up to Sunday’s Golden Globes awards, there have been criticisms of the night’s planned
“red carpet blackout”–the decision of women and men in the industry to wear black to the event–and questions of how big of an impact a fashion-based silent protest could actually make?
But the protest on the red carpet was anything but silent. The pre-show interviews were a welcome change, much less “who are you wearing” and more “why are you wearing?” The message was repeated by star after star: women are no longer tolerating the imbalance and abuses of power, not just in this industry, but all industries, all over the world. They mourned the work the world will never see from brilliant and talented women denied what could have been in their careers if not for abusive men. They spoke of the Time’s Up Legal Defense Fund, which as of this writing is just shy of its $16,000,000 goal to help women fight sexual harassment, assault, and abuse in the workplace. For all the worry that the all-black red carpet would lead to a funereal feel, the actual result was a demonstration of strength and passion.
Also inspiring was the decision by a number of women to bring activists as their dates.
Not only is everybody wearing black, but Meryl Streep, Emma Stone, Emma Watson, Laura Dern, Amy Poehler, Susan Sarandon, Michelle Williams and Shailene Woodley brought activists as their dates to show #TIMESUP #GoldenGlobes pic.twitter.com/YWFcS5gHkI
— BestLife (@BestLifeOnline) January 8, 2018
Please take a moment to read and share our official statement. The 8 of us attending the #GoldenGlobes tonight are doing so as representatives of the folks who we work on behalf. https://t.co/UeGLcnwLPz
— Tarana (@TaranaBurke) January 7, 2018
Meryl Streep brought Ai-jen Poo, director of the National Domestic Workers Alliance and co-director of the Caring Across Generations Campaign. Emma Stone brought Billie Jean King, the tennis star and gender equality activist she portrayed in Battle of the Sexes. Emma Watson brought Marai Larasi, the executive director of Imkaan, an organization dedicated to addressing violence against black women and girls, and the co-chair of the End Violence Against Women Coalition. Laura Dern brought Mónica Ramirez, co-founder of Alianza Nacional de Campesinas, fighting for the rights of farmworkers. Amy Poehler brought Saru Jayaraman, an advocate for equality and safety in the restaurant industry. Susan Sarandon brought community organizer and independent journalist Rosa Clemente. Shailene Woodley brought Calina Lawrence, a Native American advocate. Michelle Williams brought Tarana Burke, the original founder of the #MeToo movement.
“The thing that is most powerful is that it’s women across the spectrum. It’s people across all genders, all races, all classes,” says our Senior Director @TaranaBurke on today’s movement for gender equity. #GoldenGlobes #TIMESUP pic.twitter.com/pRLQkGIjtH
— Girls for Gender Equity (GGE) (@GGENYC) January 8, 2018
There were many who thought that it would have made for a stronger protest if these actresses had stayed home, boycotting the event entirely. However, when women have been held back for so long, kept from progressing to the full potential of their careers, a boycott would send a statement, but visibility is also power.
Kerry Washington said in her red carpet interview, “We shouldn’t have to stay home, to give up our seats at the table because of [men’s] bad behavior.”
At the same time, this was still a Hollywood awards show red carpet, and that comes with some hard habits to break.
Like, for instance, the commodification of a movement, creating a specific brand of glamourized activism far outside of most people’s reach.
— Andrea Mandell (@AndreaMandell) January 8, 2018
Love her, love the message. But really wish it wasn't on a $400 sweater. https://t.co/UqeQssAuN9
— Jessica Valenti (@JessicaValenti) January 8, 2018
Most notably, red carpet reporters are largely ill-equipped to handle the subjects they’ve been forced to talked about.
Jeeeeesus Christ, a red carpet correspondent on E! just said "our GLAMBOT is wearing black in solidarity!"
— rachel seville tashjian (@theprophetpizza) January 7, 2018
Clearly, they had been coached and prepped with questions and conversation topics for the women attending. But when it came to talking to the men, the conversations came up disappointingly short. There was either no mention of the movement and its representation in their outfits and the Time’s Up pins so many donned, or at best, there were some glib quips referencing the issues.
Hi please ask men on the red carpet why they continue to work with men they know are predators. Please do not ask them about their black tuxedos. #GoldenGlobes
— KB (@KaraRBrown) January 7, 2018
You know, you can ask a man about harassment too.
— Lizzie O'Leary (@lizzieohreally) January 8, 2018
On top of that, I’ve written here before about the potential shallowness of men’s participation in this movement. It’s easy to wear a pin. When these men were barely asked to even say a word about a simple accessory, they risk undermining what it represents.
You starred in Woody Allen's new movie. You built a career on malicious misogyny towards Britney Spears. You left Janet Jackson out to dry. This is pure performative fraud.
— Amoreena (@lilblondeduck) January 7, 2018
My main gripe is that had Weinstein not been exposed, he would have been here, been in black, and would have easily been considered a supporter. How many sexists and harassers are in black tonight?
— Connie Wang (@conniewang) January 8, 2018
What did you think about the Time’s Up statement on the red carpet?
Want more stories like this? Become a subscriber and support the site!
—The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—
Have a tip we should know? firstname.lastname@example.org