Skip to main content

Pennsylvania man wants to get close to his female colleague. Then he allegedly put bodily fluids in her coffee mug: ‘Did not taste right’

Probably not a good way to get close to someone.

A Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania man allegedly added bodily fluids into a female colleague’s coffee mug on several instances after having felt that it was his only way to get close to her. 45-year-old Timothy Haver has been sentenced to one to two years in county jail after pleading guilty to misdemeanor stalking on Tuesday, Nov. 17.

The victim, identified as Jane Doe in the criminal complaint filed in December and obtained by People, alleged that someone stalked and harassed her between October and November 2025 while she was at work at Highland Health. Her suspicions stemmed from when she drank from her mug, which was filled with water, and found that “it did not taste right,” the criminal complaint said. Jane Doe reportedly found a substance at the bottom of her mug, which she believed “smelled and looked like semen,” after consulting with a witness on Oct. 16, 2025.

Jane Doe reported the incident to Highmark Health’s police force and agreed to install a hidden camera in her office. Surveillance footage allegedly captured Haver secretly taking her mug from her desk and returning it afterward on two occasions. Each time, she found the same substance at the bottom of her mug, which Highmark Health police swabbed and kept as evidence, according to the criminal complaint.

Haver avoids Megan’s Law in Pennsylvania

The criminal complaint said that Haver admitted to taking and tampering with the mug and told investigators that he felt it was “his only way of getting close with her” during the interrogation. Haver, who was a manager at the time, was immediately removed from his role at Highmark Health on Nov. 20, 2025—the day Jane Doe found bodily fluid in her mug again.

Haver was initially charged with stalking and six counts of indecent assault and harassment before he took a plea deal with the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office, per People, citing court documents. The 45-year-old was also not required to register as a sex offender as part of the plea, according to WPXI.

Casey White, who represented Haver, told KDKA Radio that Haver felt remorseful and expressed hope that the victim could put the situation behind her. “Ultimately, I was able to have them agree to withdraw the counts involving the Megan’s Law registration, where he was facing 15 to 25 years of Megan’s Law registration requirement,” White said. “In return, we negotiated a plea to the misdemeanor stalking charge.”

Megan’s Law is a federal law that requires law enforcement to release relevant information on registered sex offenders for public safety. They are mandated to inform the public whenever those on the registry are present in the neighborhood to prevent victimization.

Jane Doe told WPXI that she was disappointed Haver did not have to register as a sex offender, but was relieved that “her manager will spend the next one to two years behind bars.” In her victim impact statement in court, Jane Doe said she now suffers from PTSD and becomes anxious whenever she has to accept coffee from someone following the experience, which she described as “the worst year of my life.”

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

When she isn't writing, you can easily find Robyn all bundled up and cozy while getting lost in her world of romance and Harry Potter fanfiction. She also loves playing Roblox and conquering its pixel mountains.