Skip to main content

North Carolina pub allegedly punishes ‘miserable and entitled’ diners with 20% auto tip, but owners say it’s ‘to educate people’

Their policy is meant to curb the bad tippers.

Owners of a pub have doubled down on their policy of automatically adding a 20% tip to the bills of diners with a history of poor tipping. The controversy came after a diner visited Freeman’s Grub & Pub in Greensboro, North Carolina, and shared a photo of its alleged policy in the r/EndTipping subreddit.

According to the policy shared, “If our employees have 2 separate instances of you not tipping well without any explanation, we will add a 20% autograt fee to your bill.” The pub also stated it would save receipts for any disputes, and argued that there “shouldn’t be a low tip” if diners had no issues with their staff. “On average, the tip percentage in the US is 20% or above anytime you are provided service,” it added.

Owners Kevin and Emily Purcell told the NY Post that the tipping policy had been in effect for five months, and since then, 10 regular diners have been added to their auto gratuity list—all of whom, they say, had no complaints about the policy. The couple stated that tipping below 10% when they dine in is grounds for being included on the list.

The pub owners advocate for their servers

Kevin initially responded to the backlash on the pub’s social media, defending their servers and explaining that diners should already be aware of the “rules of engagement” and expectations when dining at establishments in 2026. “Our staff is beyond competent,” Kevin said. “You’re expected to tip for the great to excellent service that they provide. That money goes to feed their kids, to take care of their families, try to survive in this economy just like everybody else.”

Kevin added that while corporate servers are encouraged to accept whatever tip they get, if they get any, “here at our mom-and-pop joint, you can kick […] rocks.” He continued, “We will stand behind our controversial policy and our amazing staff 100%.”

The pub owner was also candid about restaurant culture, saying that diners who do not tip well are frequently discussed by servers everywhere. “Servers everywhere talk s*** when you leave about how pathetic it is that you still don’t know the very basic rules of dining out at this point in your miserable, entitled existence,” Kevin said.

They say the mandatory tip is meant to educate

Freeman’s Grub & Pub’s Yelp and Google pages were allegedly flooded with negative reviews after the Reddit post, which Kevin described as coming from “a bunch of lonely Karens.” He claimed that many of the one-star reviewers had never actually visited the establishment.

The Purcells acknowledged the controversy around tipping culture in the U.S. as well, noting that not tipping doesn’t necessarily make someone unpleasant. However, they said their policy is intended to educate diners, not punish them.

“Part of the reason for this policy was to educate people,” Kevin said. “There’s a social contract when you enter a restaurant, sit down, and somebody serves you. It’s the service industry. It’s hospitality.”

The Reddit post also alleged that a 4% operating fee was added to the bill without prior disclosure. The Purcells did not address this claim in their response.

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow The Mary Sue:

When she isn't writing, you can easily find Robyn all bundled up and cozy while getting lost in her world of romance and Harry Potter fanfiction. She also loves playing Roblox and conquering its pixel mountains.