Marriage Story and How a Film Can Make You Pick Sides, Even When There Are None
What’s really interesting about Noah Baumbach’s Marriage Story is that despite how self-aware it is, and how fair it wants to be about this couple going through a divorce, many viewers are choosing sides over who deserves the blame. On social media, judgment and debate and has been raging for days.
We also find out that Charlie cheated on Nicole with a member of their company, because Nicole “stopped having sex with him in the last year” and while it is clear the affair was nothing serious on Charlie’s part, the fact that his mistress is still employed with him says a lot.
Still, Adam Driver, when he’s not Kylo Ren, is a charismatic actor, who makes these sad puppy dog faces that can motivate even the most cynical of us feel pity for his situation (somewhat, anyway). While I was never on Charlie’s side and I think the film itself sees Nicole’s perspective in this, there is something that changes when she hires Laura Dern and we see Nicole actually advocating for herself and her desires rather than just going along with the tempo that Charlie is setting.
When Nicole moves back to live with her mother in L.A. with the couple’s son, Henry, the move is intended for a test run for California to become a more permanent place in their lives. Henry ends up loving L.A., makes new friends, and gets to bond with his cousins who are the same age. Yet Charlie still thinks this is temporary even though Nicole also moved in order to film a pilot that would be potentially picked up for series.
Charlie is forced, through the legal system, to really acknowledge that his life is going to change now as he must actually compromise. He may insist that they are a New York family, but if they want to stay in L.A. then that is no longer the case. It is frustrating that he has to rent apartments on both coasts and that he is becoming more distant from his kid, but you can also see that he put himself in that situation because he didn’t listen for a big chunk of their relationship. It is a chickens coming home to roost situation for him and I have empathy, but I’m not exactly crying with him when he has his big monologue.
I spent most of Marriage Story feeling sorry for Charlie, and I think that’s unfortunate. Baumbach gave Nicole the more sympathetic backstory (Charlie is super selfish, cheated, etc.) but then told most of the story from Charlie’s perspective. We never really saw him be selfish.
— Aisling, Love Triangle Apologist (@bazineapologist) December 7, 2019
Marriage Story is all about how there isn’t a side! Charlie was a dick and Nicole was selfish! BOTH of them were wrong on all sides and if you’re trying to put one higher than the other the whole point just went over your fuckinh head!
— (@riseofben) December 7, 2019
The narrative around who’s at fault and who’s more villainized in Noah Baumbach’s MARRIAGE STORY has been interesting. For my two cents’ worth, I felt Nicole came across as clearly less sympathetic and more at fault, and I’m surprised at people who found the film even-handed. pic.twitter.com/XPMshBchIT
— Tasha Robinson (@TashaRobinson) December 6, 2019
The only thing I feel equipped to say in depth about Marriage Story at this point is I can’t help but feel the people picking sides (Team Nicole, Team Charlie, etc) kind of missed the point of the film
— Morgan DeA-Tree (@DeatleyMorgan) December 6, 2019
Okay fine. I think Marriage Story is very evenhanded and saying that Nicole is painted as a villain because she gets a high powered lawyer to go through a ~legal proceeding~ says more about viewer perceptions than the movie itself. https://t.co/wBeP60Q6AQ
— Esther Zuckerman (@ezwrites) December 7, 2019
It is also especially jarring seeing that some people on social media hate Nicole for hiring a lawyer when it is clear that she has felt railroaded throughout their entire marriage. As some have pointed out, if we’re picking sides, we may have missed the point. I may not be a child of divorce, but I know that divorce, even when it’s amicable, is not easy when it comes to carving out clear lines and boundaries between two people who once shared everything. Especially when a young child is involved.
While there are moments of “selfishness” from Nicole it is not malicious, she is trying to find the person she was again without her husband of ten years. Trying to advocate for her needs and wants, and that isn’t easy. And the reason it hits Charlie so hard is that he’s used to her being flexible to his whims.
Well not anymore.
Want more stories like this? Become a subscriber and support the site!
—The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—
Have a tip we should know? email@example.com