ICE rearrested immigrants minutes after they walked free on judges’ orders. A federal judge says it made a ‘mockery of court orders’
Courts shouldn't have to repeat themselves.

A federal judge in Colorado found U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials in contempt of court over the agency’s practice of re-arresting immigrants within minutes of their court-ordered release. The judge wrote in her ruling that the practice made a “mockery of court orders.”
In a 15-page ruling issued on November 18, U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney found ICE officials in contempt for violating a court-ordered release. She declined to impose penalties after an agency official testified that the practice had stopped.
The case involved Ramon Quintero Alvarez, who was born in Mexico and had lived in the United States for more than 30 years. According to the court ruling, Alvarez had been detained by ICE since February 2026, despite the charges underlying his most recent arrest being dropped in April. He filed a habeas petition asking a federal judge for release, arguing that his continued detention was unlawful. After the government failed to show why he should remain detained, Sweeney ordered his release by October 27, Colorado Public Radio reported.
ICE officials try to defend their immediate re-arrests
ICE arrested Alvarez again moments after he walked out of the detention facility into a public area. During court proceedings, Nichole Black, an assistant field office director for ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations, testified that she had received a “direct order” to re-detain habeas petitioners “that had some type of criminality.” She also agreed it was “fair” to say she had inaccurate information about whether Alvarez had any pending charges, according to the ruling.
Black also said she believed ICE could escort someone into a public area before immediately arresting them again, even when a court had ordered their release. Acting Field Office Director Nathan Rasper, whose order was passed down to Black, later testified that he heard he could re-arrest people based on a policy in Minnesota.
Sweeney, however, rejected the justification, writing that all individuals, “whatever their position in government, are subject to federal law.” “Lest there be any confusion: All orders and judgments of courts must be complied with promptly,” she added.
“ICE’s new ‘policy’ of immediately re-detaining petitioners following release made a mockery of court orders mandating petitioners’ immediate release,” Sweeney wrote in her ruling. The judge also stressed that disobeying a court order does not have to be intentional to constitute civil contempt.
According to Colorado Public Radio, the court also learned that at least 18 people in Colorado had either been detained beyond their court-ordered release dates or re-arrested within minutes of being released over the preceding six weeks. Immigration attorneys believe the actual number could be higher, including cases involving immigrants representing themselves in court.
The judge stopped short of penalties after ICE said the practice ended
Despite the contempt finding, Sweeney declined to take further action after Rasper testified that ICE had stopped immediately re-arresting immigrants released through habeas corpus petitions. The judge wrote that the government had “cured the contempt by ceasing the practice at issue.”
Colorado Public Radio reported that Sweeney’s ruling signaled she could reopen the matter if there were more violations. ICE and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Reuters, and U.S. Attorney Peter McNeilly, whose office represented the government, had no comment, according to CPR. The Trump administration has maintained that its immigration actions comply with the law, per Reuters.
The Colorado ruling comes as ICE faces accusations of defying court orders in other cases. The Guardian identified at least 20 cases nationwide in which immigrants were re-arrested after winning release through habeas corpus petitions, citing court records, attorneys, and media reports.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]