American Airlines passengers fear the brown substance coating their bags in Atlanta is human waste, but the airline says it’s something else
I'd need a lot more than a statement before I believed that much peanut butter came out of one suitcase.

Passengers on American Airlines Flight 2609 from Miami reportedly found dozens of their bags coated in a brown substance at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on Monday night, and many feared it was human waste. American Airlines has reportedly denied that, saying the mess was liquefied peanut butter that leaked from one passenger’s checked bag during the flight, according to The New York Post.
The flight reportedly landed around 8:30 PM, and passengers said they waited more than two hours before the bags reached carousel 8. In a TikTok video posted by Derick McCallum, one passenger can be heard saying, “Now they’re bringing the bags out. There is doo-doo on the bags.” McCallum said travelers started yelling once the bags dropped onto the carousel.
Passenger Billy Johnson said travelers were already frustrated by the lengthy delay when the stained bags finally came around. “Everybody started saying, you know, ‘This is poop. This is poop.’ I’m like, surely to God not, right?” Johnson said. Passengers were reportedly left to salvage their own luggage with disinfecting wipes and tissues before heading home.
Not everyone is ready to take the airline’s word for it
American Airlines said in a statement that it was “very sorry for the experience.” However, some passengers reportedly remain skeptical of the peanut butter explanation, questioning whether a single leaking container could reach that many bags. Reports so far have not said how much peanut butter was involved or what it was packed in.
McCallum questioned the explanation directly. “Even if somebody did pack peanut butter? How much peanut butter does somebody pack to cover that many bags?” McCallum said. In the video, he also appeared to suggest the delay was linked to a flooded luggage compartment, a claim that has not been independently verified.
The airline’s statement, as reported, did not address what caused the long wait at baggage claim. It also did not say whether affected passengers would be reimbursed for cleaning or replacing their luggage. American Airlines has not publicly shared the results of any inspection of the aircraft’s cargo hold.
Peanut butter is runnier than most travelers give it credit for
The TSA treats peanut butter as a liquid, allowing only 3.4 ounces or less in carry-on bags but larger amounts in checked luggage. It does so as peanut butter has no definite shape and takes the shape of its container. Ted Heindel, a mechanical engineer who studies fluid flows, has written that it fits the scientific definition of a liquid.
Passengers have mistaken other substances for sewage at baggage claim before. Virgin Atlantic travelers arriving at New York’s JFK Airport last year found suitcases coated in a foul-smelling brown residue, which the Terminal 4 operator traced to grease from a faulty kitchen pipe. However, the airline said that contamination happened inside the airport rather than on the plane.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]