How Many Cinderella Adaptations Do We Need?
Images from the upcoming Cinderella musical romantic comedy directed by Kay Cannon were shared over the weekend. Starring singer Camila Cabello, Disney Princess Idina Menzel, and gay icon Billy Porter, the movie is promising to be a “feminist” version of the story, to which I say: sure, okay.
First images of Camila Cabello in Kay Cannon’s live-action Cinderella which also stars James Corden, Idina Menzel, Pierce Brosnan, John Mulaney & Billy Porter as a gender neutral Fairy Godmother. The film will take on a “feminist twist” & will be released on February 5, 2021. pic.twitter.com/afHiSUMMtv
— Film Updates (@FilmUpdates) September 27, 2020
Considering that over the weekend I watched the 2015 Disney remake of Cinderella, and Ever After is also now on Disney+ along with the animated Cinderella films, it just reminded me of how often we have done either a Cinderella film or something Cinderella related.
Also, as Mary Sue contributor Anya Crittenton has written before, the character of Cinderella “can be one of the most feminist, tenacious, and kind female characters,” and “she’s a princess who saves herself just as much as any other one with a sword or daring journey. The way her story is told through modern adaptations shows the evolution of both the story and evolving ideas about feminism and representation.”
We have seen Cinderella as a kind person who, despite being a victim of abuse and neglect, treats people with kindness. Feminism is something that gets put as a standard for any film with a female lead, especially these newer fairy tale adaptations that are trying to go beyond the usual ways we have depicted these characters.
I certainly think there are feminist elements to Cinderella the character, and as I’ve gotten older, seeing someone be kind in the face of cruelty is something that I find deeply inspiring. But it’s been done before. Even with casting a Latina actress, Camila Cabello, as Cinderella, they picked a white Latina, and most of the supporting cast is white.
Billy Porter playing the non-gendered fairy godparent is also interesting on paper, and I’m glad he gets to be in a fairy tale, but why not someone who is actually non-binary?
If we are going to make more Cinderella films, then the bar of “feminism” needs to be raised because Drew Barrymore already carried a prince on her back. Brandy and Keke Palmer both melanated diversity to their roles, and Brandy gave us an Asian prince. What’s next?
The 2015 remake with Lily James and Richard Madden was peak White Excellence Cinderella. At this point, it’s time to be fully non-white, queer, or something because we have multiple feminist versions of this fairy tale. I’m excited that this version will be directed and written by a woman; yay for female directors, but to quote Derek from The Swan Princess:
(image: Sony Pictures Releasing)
Want more stories like this? Become a subscriber and support the site!
—The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]