‘Absolutely slammed’: Server removed the auto-gratuity from a $90 check. Then the party of 8 tipped her exactly $18
A busy restaurant shift can become overwhelming fast. For one server, Saturday got so hectic that she wasn’t willing to gamble on a large table leaving a decent tip.
Automatic gratuity can protect servers handling large parties. However, not every customer likes having a tip added for them. One party of eight apparently wanted another option.
According to TikTok creator Sophie (@sophiealtheaw), she was “absolutely slammed” while working mostly alone. When a party of eight walked in, she decided to add a 20% automatic gratuity rather than take her chances.
That didn’t sit right with everyone
Sophie explained that Saturdays would normally mean having coworkers around to help. That day, however, one employee had to leave early, while Sophie ended up working overtime. She claims she had no food expo, bussers, hosts, or manager on duty.
Her workload kept growing. In the caption, Sophie said she was handling two parties of six, a party of five, a family of four, two couples, and the newly arrived party of eight.
At her restaurant, servers can add a 20% automatic gratuity for groups of eight or more. Sophie said she usually prefers to let customers determine their own tip. Given how overwhelming the shift had become, however, she didn’t want to risk doing the work for a large table and walking away with little to show for it.
Before taking the group’s order, Sophie informed them that a 20% gratuity would be added to their check. That immediately became a problem.
“We don’t want to do that,” she recalled them responding. According to Sophie, the diners even asked whether they could sit at two separate tables instead. She offered to lower the gratuity to 18%, but the group remained concerned about the charge.
Two people eventually left, reducing the party to six. Sophie continued taking everyone’s orders, only for those two diners to return later and order as well.
By that point, however, Sophie had reconsidered the entire situation. She wondered whether the diners were worried about money and decided against automatically adding the gratuity.
That distinction mattered to her. Some customers have reacted strongly after finding automatic gratuity already included on a restaurant bill, and this group had made its feelings clear before the food was even ordered. Sophie decided to give them the choice they had wanted.
When she dropped off their split checks, she specifically explained that she had removed the automatic gratuity. “There’s no tip on there,” she recalled telling them. “You can tip me what you’d like.”
The group’s choices had also kept the final bill relatively low. Sophie said they mostly ordered waters with lemon, while the children’s drinks came free with their kids’ meals. Some diners shared food rather than ordering individual meals. Altogether, the checks came to around $90.
Then Sophie added up the tips. Across all the separate checks, the party had left her exactly $18. That is 20% of a $90 bill—the same percentage they had objected to having automatically added in the first place. “All of that commotion for a 20% tip,” Sophie said.
The irony wasn’t lost on viewers. One commenter recalled removing an 18% automatic gratuity from a customer’s bill and ultimately receiving a 30% tip instead. “I guess ppl just like having the choice,” they wrote.
Others were far less willing to take that chance. “ALWAYS AUTO GRAT!!!” one person commented. Another shared, “I work at a place where every check during brunch (when I work) is 20% autograt no matter the party size and it kinda rocks.”
Sophie ultimately made $400 during the shift, but the money apparently did little to change how exhausting the day had been. “I made $400 but it wasn’t worth it,” she said. “I’m just so over today.”
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
