Yesterday, Rep. Ed Case (D-Hawaii) attended an event celebrating the Asian-American and Pacific Islander members of Congress. While speaking at the event, Case stated, “I’m an Asian trapped in a white body.” Oof buddy, what are you doing? The story went viral after National Journal data and visualization fellow Nicholas Wu tweeted it to his followers.
Congressman Ed Case, who represents a majority Asian district in Honolulu – “I’m an Asian trapped in a white body” pic.twitter.com/Roro6Yk8CW
— Nicholas Wu (@nicholaswu12) January 16, 2019
Twitter quickly took Case to task for his insensitive comments.
This ain’t it, Ed Case https://t.co/eQRMgbbTvb
— Jeff Yang (@originalspin) January 16, 2019
WTF. As a haole who lived in Japan for 7 years and now lives in Hawaiʻi, I couldn’t imagine saying something like this. Check your privilege Ed Case. https://t.co/7kLkFFGOGx
— 808progressive (@808Progressive) January 16, 2019
Alexa, what’s the worst possible thing Ed Case could say?
— It is Happening Here (@jrrogersjr) January 16, 2019
Ed Case GF (in a shell) pic.twitter.com/9BfNrwzin4
— Michael Fishman (@MJFishman) January 16, 2019
Ed Case pic LEAKED pic.twitter.com/FHF9yXIVYb
— Michael Fishman (@MJFishman) January 16, 2019
So I guess Emma Stone will play Ed Case in the movie.
— Saint Grobian (@Saint_Grobian) January 16, 2019
I wonder if Tilda or Scarlett will play the Asian trapped in Ed Case’s body https://t.co/hoVLxbi41z
— Rekha PRANKar (@rekhalshankar) January 16, 2019
Case issued an apology via the Washington Post, saying “Like so many others from Hawaii who treasure our multicultural heritage, I have absorbed and live the values of our many cultures … They and not my specific ethnicity are who I am, and I believe that this makes me an effective advocate on national issues affecting our API community. I regret if my specific remarks to the national API community on my full absorption of their concerns caused any offense.”
I mean … okay, that’s sort of an apology, I guess? And it’s great that you’ve “absorbed” different values and cultures but … at the end of the day, you’re still a white guy. In addition to Case’s statement, his spokesman Nestor Garcia added that Case’s comments were in reference to “what his Japanese-American wife sometimes says about him.”
(image: FOX)
Here’s the thing: Case is not pulling a Rachel Dolezal here. He knows he is white, and he clearly has enthusiasm for Asian culture. But he’s going about it in a wildly insensitive and wrongheaded way. When a white person proclaims themselves to be a nonwhite race/ethnicity trapped inside a white body, they are discounting and dismissing the systemic racism and oppression that is inescapable for folks of that race or ethnicity.
It is peak white privilege, and it shares the same cultural voyeurism of straight women saying that they are “gay men on the inside.” These are marginalized communities that have suffered under discrimination and mistreatment since time immemorial, not a fashionable token to brag about how woke you are.
Race, ethnicity, class, sexuality, gender: these are not accessories to fit your mood: they are lived experiences and identities. If Ed Case really feels an affinity for Asian culture, he should know better than to insult it in this way. Fellow white people, it’s only January. Let’s be better than this, yes?
(via Washington Post, image: Paramount Pictures)
Want more stories like this? Become a subscriber and support the site!
—The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—
