‘He Never Knew a Stranger’: Police Went Onto a Woman’s Land Searching for a Missing Child, but They Shot Her Pet Donkey Instead
"Heehaws life has no monetary value."
Hannah Israel says a police officer shot and killed her pet donkey, HeeHaw, after entering her land in Cedartown, Georgia, without permission. According to LADbible, officers were searching for a missing child around 12:45 a.m. on Sunday, Aug. 30, when the miniature donkey ran up to them braying.
Israel says police told her they believed they were in danger and shot HeeHaw after first trying to Tase him. She described the bottle-fed donkey as “her son,” raised in the house and used in petting zoos. “HeeHaw was raised in the house and did petting zoos, he never knew a stranger,” she wrote on Facebook. “And was shot and killed in his OWN pasture for doing what donkeys do. Alerting to a stranger.”
Israel also said officers didn’t tell her where HeeHaw had been killed. It took her family around 20 minutes of searching to find his body. The city of Cedartown confirmed the officer involved has been placed on paid administrative leave while the shooting is investigated.
Whether the Search Itself Was Legal Depends on Where It Happened
In a statement, the city said an officer was on scene assisting Polk County Police with the missing-child search when the shooting occurred. The child was later found safe at a nearby church. Cedartown said it turned the shooting investigation over to the Georgia Department of Agriculture’s Law Enforcement Division and couldn’t comment further. The Polk County Sheriff’s Office said it wasn’t involved and extended condolences to Israel’s family. The outlet said it has reached out to the Cedartown Police Department for comment.
Whether officers needed permission to be on Israel’s land at all comes down to a specific Fourth Amendment rule. It’s known as the open fields doctrine, established in the 1924 Supreme Court case Hester v. United States. It was reaffirmed in 1984’s Oliver v. United States. Under this doctrine, police generally don’t need a warrant or the owner’s consent to enter open land like a pasture, even when it’s fenced or posted against trespassing.
That protection only exists for a home’s immediate surroundings, known as curtilage, not for open farmland further out. A search for a missing child would also independently qualify as an exigent circumstance. That’s a recognized exception letting officers act quickly without a warrant during a genuine emergency.
The shooting itself is a separate legal question from the entry onto the land. Multiple federal appeals courts, including the Fourth, Sixth, and Seventh Circuits, have ruled on this exact issue. They’ve found that unreasonably killing a pet can count as an unconstitutional seizure of property under the Fourth Amendment. Courts applying this standard generally ask whether the animal posed an immediate danger. They also ask whether deadly force was truly unavoidable. That’s the same question Georgia’s Department of Agriculture investigation will likely have to answer here.
Israel has since launched a GoFundMe to help cover legal fees. It had raised $116,000 of a $170,000 goal at the time of writing. In an update, she said she’s hired a lawyer independent of the fundraiser. She said leftover donations will go toward the farm’s animals and a planned HeeHaw foundation. “This is not a pay day for us,” she wrote. “Heehaws life has no monetary value.”
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
Follow The Mary Sue:
